Restaurant

Middletown, NY Restaurants for Lease

Notify Me
List
Map
New Hampton, NY Slate Hill, NY Goshen, NY Otisville, NY Bloomingburg, NY Florida, NY Warwick, NY Camp Bell Hall, NY
Found 6 restaurant listings for lease in Middletown, NY, averaging $32/SF/YR. Use lease type data to compare options faster.
Restaurant Space with Basement
Updated: Aug 10
Restaurant Space with Basement

33 Center Street, Middletown, NY 10940

$3,500/Mo
0.06 AC lot
Restaurant/bar space with prior tavern and restaurant use
General construction underway after removal of flooring and bar
Small kitchen requiring evaluation for restaurant operations
Directly across from City Hall and next to the public library
0.0609‑acre site with brick construction and basement
View details
Restaurant with Outdoor Beer Garden
Updated: Sep 25
Restaurant with Outdoor Beer Garden

22 Cottage Street, Middletown, NY 10940

$22 SF/Yr
0.19 AC lot
Restaurant build‑out with indoor and outdoor areas
Outdoor beer garden described as approximately 7,500, with no unit specified
Configurable interior layout; outdoor area can accommodate events, live music, and overflow seating
19th‑century building at 22 Cottage Street in Middletown
At the Orange County Heritage Trail terminus, with adjacent municipal parking
View details
Retail Space with Drive-Through
Retail Space with Drive-Through

4932 Route 17M, Middletown, NY 10958

$6,000/Mo
1,800–2,000 sqft
22,000 VPD

A service area within a convenience store and gas station offers counter and table service options.

Drive-thru  Counter service  Table service  Storage
View details
Restaurant Space
Restaurant Space

33 Center Street #29, Middletown, NY 10940

$3,500/Mo
3,279 sqft

The owner is completing general construction; specialized tenant improvements remain the tenant’s responsibility.

View details
Retail Space in Private Building
Retail Space in Private Building

129 Lake Avenue, Middletown, NY 10940

$2,250/Mo
441 sqft
Highway access

The space carries I-1 zoning and is available for rent.

View details
Prime Retail Pad Sites Available
Prime Retail Pad Sites Available

31 Orange Plz Ln, Middletown, NY

Contact for pricing
5,112 sqft

Pad sites available in regional power center with high visibility.

View details
6 active listings match your search: Restaurant for lease in Middletown, NY. Based on your search, we've also compiled 16 Potential Opportunities for your consideration: 4 spaces in nearby cities and 12 properties for sale.

Restaurants for Lease in Nearby Cities

Here are 4 Similar Spaces we found in Nearby Locations for your consideration.

Waterfront Bar and Pub
Waterfront Bar and Pub

634 Jersey Avenue, Greenwood Lake, NY 10925

$3,000/Mo
5,550 sqft  100 seats
3,600 VPD

Indoor and outdoor dining accommodates 100 guests, with a raised sunroom extending over the water.

Patio
View details
Freestanding Restaurant with Patio
Freestanding Restaurant with Patio

Branchville, NJ 07826

$2,250/Mo
1,215 sqft

Renovated restaurant space includes a rear outdoor dining area and shared parking.

20 parking spaces  Patio
View details
Lakefront Restaurant
Lakefront Restaurant

634 Jersey, Greenwood Lake, NJ 10925

$3,000/Mo
1,500 sqft  100 seats  Built 1984

Indoor and outdoor seating accommodates 100 guests, with commercial-grade kitchen equipment and public water.

View details
Retail Restaurant Space
Retail Restaurant Space

Branchville, NJ 07826

$6,000/Mo

For rent on US Highway 206 Southbound, offering flexible retail and foodservice potential for the right operator.

20 parking spaces
View details

Similar Spaces for Sale in Middletown, NY

Consider Similar Space for Sale. We found 12 Spaces matching your search parameters.

Mixed-Use Building with Kitchen
Mixed-Use Building with Kitchen

33 Center Street, Middletown, NY 10940

$699,000
0.06 AC lot

The upper floor may accommodate three one-bedroom apartments, subject to municipal and building-code approvals.

View details
Mixed-Use Building with Restaurant
Mixed-Use Building with Restaurant

28 Henry Street, Middletown, NY 10940

$1,795,000
0.14 AC lot

Multi-level property includes production space, a full basement, and dedicated lift access.

View details
Mixed-Use Property with Luncheonette
Mixed-Use Property with Luncheonette

1197 Dolsontown Road, Middletown, NY 10940

$899,000
1.20 AC lot

An operating luncheonette shares the property with residential space upstairs that requires work.

View details
Renovated Mixed-Use Building
Renovated Mixed-Use Building

39 W Main Street, Middletown, NY 10940

$1,299,000
0.04 AC lot

Standalone property combining four residential units with an operating ground-floor restaurant near downtown amenities.

View details
Commercial Land with Restaurant
Commercial Land with Restaurant

2850 State Route 17k, Middletown, NY 10941

$1,800,000
1,754 sqft

Two adjoining parcels combine an operating restaurant and a rented single-family home.

View details
Multi-Level Mixed-Use Property
Multi-Level Mixed-Use Property

28 Henry St Unit 22, Middletown, NY 10940

$1,795,000

Restaurant occupancy accompanies production space, a full basement, and dedicated lift access.

View details
Multi-Level Mixed-Use Property
Multi-Level Mixed-Use Property

22-28 Henry St, Middletown, NY 10940

$1,795,000

Multi-level building with restaurant occupancy, industrial production space, basement, and lift access.

View details
Equipped Restaurant Business
Equipped Restaurant Business

540 Bloomingburg Road, Middletown, NY 10940

$125,000
2.60 AC lot

Restaurant business sale includes furnishings, bar service, kitchen equipment, and walk-in coolers.

View details
Renovated Brewery and Event Venue
Renovated Brewery and Event Venue

22 Cottage Street, Middletown, NY 10940

$2,575,000
0.83 AC lot

Multi-area brewery property with residential apartments, event facilities, and outdoor entertaining space.

View details
Equipped Deli and Bakery Business
Equipped Deli and Bakery Business

390 Crystal Run Rd Unit 103, Middletown, NY 10941

$130,000

Established food-service business with a commercial kitchen and customer-facing service equipment in a leased location.

View details
Historic Tavern Restaurant Opportunity
Historic Tavern Restaurant Opportunity

746 Main St, Middletown, NY 13775

$499,000

Turnkey restaurant in Margaretville with outdoor seating and equipment.

View details
Golf Course and Driving Range
Golf Course and Driving Range

42565 Route 28, Middletown, NY 12455

$799,000
23.38 AC lot

Multi-use recreational property with golf, food service, event facilities, and river frontage.

View details

Middletown, NY Restaurants Lease Rates & Market Statistics

Explore 6 Restaurants for lease in Middletown, NY on Realmo, a commercial real estate exchange covering the Middletown area. The current inventory totals 8,832 square feet of properties.

Asking lease rates for Restaurants in Middletown start at $12.81 SF/Yr, average $32.01 SF/Yr, and reach $61.22 SF/Yr at the top of the market. That's a 5x spread between entry-level and premium space, making side-by-side comparison of asking rents and lease terms essential. At $32.01 SF/Yr, the local average runs 35% below New York's state average of $49.29 SF/Yr.

Middletown accounts for 43% of the 14 restaurants currently available across Orange County, where nearby markets include Chester and Greenwood Lake. By space type, the market includes 4 conventional restaurants and 3 bars & pubs — bars & pubs typically offer the lowest entry point, while conventional restaurants command the highest rates.

List
Map
Why this one?