Add Listing
    Shelter Island, NY
    For Sale
    • For Sale
    • For Lease
    • Recently Sold
    • Property Lookup
    • Brokers
    Property Types
    1
    • Retail
    • Office
    • Residential Income
    • Restaurants
    • Industrial
    • Mixed-Use
    • Hospitality
    • Health Care
    • Sports & Entertainment
    • Land
    • Agricultural
    • Specialty
    Price
    Price
    $
    $

    Shelter Island, NY Specialty Properties for Sale

    Notify Me
    List
    Map
    Greenport, NY Southold, NY Sag Harbor, NY
    Shelter Island Home For Sale
    $2,500,000
    1,632 SF

    Shelter Island Home For Sale

    25 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island, NY

    Residential property in The Hamptons, Shelter Island, New York.

    • Located in The Hamptons
    • Priced at $2,500,000 USD
    • Marketed By Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
    • Property Type: Other Residential Home
    • School District: Shelter Island Union Free
    Updated: Nov 27, 2025
    View details
    Based on your search, we've compiled 14 Potential Opportunities for your consideration. Besides 1 Active listings in Shelter Island, NY, we suggest exploring several alternatives: 4 properties in Nearby Cities, and similar 5 Off-Market properties to explore as potential leads, plus 4 Land Listings that present a potential for development.

    Opportunities in Nearby Cities

    Here are 4 Similar properties we found in Nearby Locations for your consideration.

    Renovated Farmhouse Near Hampton Bays
    $2,395,000
    2,804 SF

    Renovated Farmhouse Near Hampton Bays

    Meticulously renovated farmhouse near the ocean, shops, and dining.

    11 Shinnecock Road, Hampton Bays, NY 11946
    View details
    Funeral Home Business and Property
    $2,800,000
    4,046 SF

    Funeral Home Business and Property

    Established funeral home with real estate on 1.2 acres.

    94 E Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, NY 11946
    View details
    Waterfront Commercial Opportunity in Westbrook
    $1,900,000
    1,600 SF

    Waterfront Commercial Opportunity in Westbrook

    Marina with restaurant potential in Westbrook's thriving marine district.

    314 Boston Post Road, Westbrook, CT 06498
    View details
    Waterfront Marina with Restaurant Potential
    $1,900,000
    1,600 SF

    Waterfront Marina with Restaurant Potential

    Marina with restaurant opportunity in Westbrook's thriving marine district.

    314 Boston Post Road, Westbrook, CT 6498
    View details

    Potential Development Sites for Consideration

    Can't find the perfect fit? These Land listings present an alternative path: the potential to develop a property for your specific goals.

    Important: These AI-suggestions are a starting point, not a guarantee of permitted use. All zoning, permitting, and land use information must be independently verified by you with the appropriate local authorities before making any commitments.

    Waterfront Land in Remsenburg, NY
    $21,000,000
    6.20 Acres

    Waterfront Land in Remsenburg, NY

    6.2 acres of waterfront property with 900 feet of shoreline.

    42 Dock Road, Remsenburg, NY 11960
    View details
    Block Island Waterfront Land
    $1,800,000
    1.90 Acres

    Block Island Waterfront Land

    Land with ocean views near the historic Southeast Lighthouse.

    Southeast Road, Block Island, RI 02807
    View details
    80+ Acre Development Opportunity
    $1,550,000
    83.12 Acres

    80+ Acre Development Opportunity

    Large residential development land with easy highway access.

    Tolland Stage Road, Tolland, CT 06084
    View details
    Brewster, NY Commercial Land
    $700,000
    2.14 Acres

    Brewster, NY Commercial Land

    2.14 acre commercial land suitable for various development projects.

    1553 22 Route, Brewster, NY 10509
    View details

    Off-Market Properties in Shelter Island, NY

    Consider similar Off-Market properties in Shelter Island, NY. You may contact the owners directly to inquire about their potential intentions to sell. To help you make a strong first impression, we can assist by reaching out to these owners with compelling proposals created using our AI tool.

    1 Bateman Rd

    1 Bateman Rd

    PROFESSIONAL CLUBS/ASSOCIATIONS • 3,792 SF
    Value Estimation by Request
    1 Bateman Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    Shelter Island, NY 11964

    Shelter Island, NY 11964

    SBE - SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS
    Value Estimation by Request
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    Shelter Island, NY 11964

    Shelter Island, NY 11964

    SBE - SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS
    Value Estimation by Request
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    Shelter Island, NY 11964

    Shelter Island, NY 11964

    SBE - SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS
    Value Estimation by Request
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    Shelter Island, NY 11964

    Shelter Island, NY 11964

    SBE - SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS
    Value Estimation by Request
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details

    Shelter Island, NY Specialty Properties Investment Opportunities Market Analysis

    Explore 6 specialty properties for sale in Shelter Island, NY on our real estate platform. These investment opportunities span a total of 1,632 square feet of properties for sale, with an estimated market value of $2,500,000.

    Sale prices for properties in Shelter Island, NY start at $2,500,000, averaging $2,500,000, and reaching up to $2,500,000 — offering options for a variety of budgets and business needs. Daily updated analytics ensure you stay ahead with the latest data and market trends.

    List
    Map

    Demographics Overview

    Population 2,858
    Median Household Income $129,826
    College Educated 80.7%

    Need Help?

    Reach out if you need assistance with Realmo tools or have questions about your listings

    Browse Specialty properties for Sale Near Shelter Island, NY

    Popular Searches in Shelter Island, NY

    Select Neighborhood

    Google sign-in failed. Please try again or use another login method.
    Sign Up Successful!
    You now have access to more from Realmo!