Realmo

Buy
- For Sale
- Post a Listing
Property Types
- Land
  
  Waterfront
- Specialty
Rent
Analytics
- Analytics Center
- Insight Report
- Recently Sold
- Value Estimation
- Cap Rate
- Ownership Records
- Location Intelligence
- Business Placement
- Off-Market Leads
- Zoning Insight

Advertise Sign In

For Sale
- Land
  - Waterfront
- Specialty
For Lease
Analytics Center
Insight Report
Recently Sold
Value Estimation
Cap Rate
Ownership Records
Location Intelligence
Business Placement
Off-Market Leads
Zoning Insight
Advertise
Find Brokers

Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island, NY Commercial Real Estate for Sale

List

Map

Greenport, NY Sag Harbor, NY Southold, NY

Shelter Island Home For Sale

Updated: Nov 27, 2025

Shelter Island Home For Sale

25 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island, NY

$2,500,000

1,632 sqft · 0.36 AC lot

Located in The Hamptons
Priced at $2,500,000 USD
Marketed By Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
Property Type: Other Residential Home
School District: Shelter Island Union Free

Turn Any Listing Into an Investment Snapshot Owner equity, real caprate, demand score for every listing. Go To Analytics Center

Based on your search, we've compiled 76 Potential Opportunities for your consideration. Besides 1 Active listings in Shelter Island, NY, we suggest exploring several alternatives: 4 properties in Nearby Cities, and similar 71 Off-Market properties to explore as potential leads

Opportunities in Nearby Cities

Here are 4 Similar properties we found in Nearby Locations for your consideration.

Two-Story Restaurant with Tiki Bar

Two-Story Restaurant with Tiki Bar

48 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944

$2,850,000

0.12 AC lot

Updated two-story restaurant offering two indoor bars, live music stage, and a large outdoor deck.

Undeveloped Land in Paradise Point

Undeveloped Land in Paradise Point

11200 N Bayview Road, Southold, NY 11971

$1,499,000

5.25 AC lot

5.25 acres of wooded land in Southold, New York.

North Fork Retail Opportunity

North Fork Retail Opportunity

57190 Route 25, Southold, NY

$899,000

2,606 sqft · 0.67 AC lot

Retail property in Hamlet Business District with ample parking.

Greenport Village Mixed-Use Investment

Greenport Village Mixed-Use Investment

30 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944

Contact for pricing

4,048 sqft

Mixed-use property in Greenport Village with restaurant, bar, apartments.

Off-Market Properties in Shelter Island, NY

Consider similar Off-Market properties in Shelter Island, NY. You may contact the owners directly to inquire about their potential intentions to sell. To help you make a strong first impression, we can assist by reaching out to these owners with compelling proposals created using our AI tool.

OFFICE BUILDING

144 Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$855,000

Estimated value

1,174 sqft · 0.82 AC lot

RESTAURANT

27 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Value Estimation by Request

2,180 sqft · 0.22 AC lot

VACANT COMMERCIAL LAND

5 Grand Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Value Estimation by Request

0.22 AC lot

OFFICE/RESIDENTIAL (MIXED USE)

6 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Value Estimation by Request

1,848 sqft · 1.40 AC lot

14th N Cartwright Rd

VACANT COMMERCIAL LAND

14th N Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Value Estimation by Request

1.70 AC lot

OFFICE BUILDING

38 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$2,640,000

Estimated value

3,979 sqft · 0.56 AC lot

SHOW ROOM, WAREHOUSE

87 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$2,070,000

Estimated value

1,984 sqft · 1.62 AC lot

STORE/OFFICE (MIXED USE)

25 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Value Estimation by Request

1,262 sqft · 0.28 AC lot

OFFICE/RESIDENTIAL (MIXED USE)

19 Grand Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$1,455,000

Estimated value

4,500 sqft · 0.14 AC lot

SHOW ROOM, WAREHOUSE

75 Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$630,000

Estimated value

3,140 sqft · 0.62 AC lot

SHOW ROOM, WAREHOUSE

188 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$3,210,000

Estimated value

2,073 sqft · 0.22 AC lot

RESTAURANT

29 Nck Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$1,005,000

Estimated value

3,868 sqft · 0.54 AC lot

PROFESSIONAL BUILDING

59 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$770,000

Estimated value

1,016 sqft · 0.50 AC lot

SHOW ROOM, WAREHOUSE

71 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964-2422

Value Estimation by Request

1,756 sqft · 1.17 AC lot

RETAIL STORES (PERSONAL SERVICES)

74 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$620,000

Estimated value

2,163 sqft · 1.70 AC lot

VACANT COMMERCIAL LAND

26 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Value Estimation by Request

2.60 AC lot

SHOW ROOM, WAREHOUSE

52nd N Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964-2414

Value Estimation by Request

2,782 sqft · 0.11 AC lot

OFFICE/RESIDENTIAL (MIXED USE)

41 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Value Estimation by Request

1,846 sqft · 1.20 AC lot

OFFICE/RESIDENTIAL (MIXED USE)

36 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Value Estimation by Request

2,588 sqft · 0.14 AC lot

OFFICE/RESIDENTIAL (MIXED USE)

40 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964-2414

Value Estimation by Request

2,135 sqft · 0.74 AC lot

SHOPPING CENTER, STRIP CENTER

21 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Value Estimation by Request

3,454 sqft · 0.42 AC lot

STORE/OFFICE (MIXED USE)

53 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Value Estimation by Request

2,490 sqft · 0.25 AC lot

RESTAURANT

85 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Value Estimation by Request

1,782 sqft · 0.23 AC lot

Shelter Island, NY Commercial Real Estate Market Trends and Statistics

Explore 72 commercial real estate for sale in Shelter Island, NY on our real estate platform. These investment opportunities span a total of 1,632 square feet of properties for sale, with an estimated market value of $2,500,000.

Sale prices for business properties in Shelter Island, NY start at $2,500,000, averaging $2,500,000, and reaching up to $2,500,000 — offering options for a variety of budgets and business needs. Daily updated analytics ensure you stay ahead with the latest data and market trends.

List

Map

Demographics Overview

Population 2,858

Median Household Income $129,826

College Educated 80.7%

Listings Trend

New vs delisted commercial listings in Suffolk County

New Delisted

Total CRE Inventory on Market (SF)

Need Help?

Reach out if you need assistance with Realmo tools or have questions about your listings