Add Listing
    Shelter Island, NY
    For Sale
    • For Sale
    • For Lease
    • Recently Sold
    • Property Lookup
    • Brokers
    Property Types
    • Retail
    • Office
    • Residential Income
    • Restaurants
    • Industrial
    • Mixed-Use
    • Hospitality
    • Health Care
    • Sports & Entertainment
    • Land
    • Agricultural
    • Specialty
    Price
    Price
    $
    $

    Shelter Island, NY Commercial Real Estate for Sale

    Notify Me
    List
    Map
    Greenport, NY Southold, NY Sag Harbor, NY
    Shelter Island Home For Sale
    $2,500,000
    1,632 SF

    Shelter Island Home For Sale

    25 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island, NY

    Residential property in The Hamptons, Shelter Island, New York.

    • Located in The Hamptons
    • Priced at $2,500,000 USD
    • Marketed By Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty
    • Property Type: Other Residential Home
    • School District: Shelter Island Union Free
    Updated: Nov 27, 2025
    View details
    Based on your search, we've compiled 104 Potential Opportunities for your consideration. Besides 1 Active listings in Shelter Island, NY, we suggest exploring several alternatives: 4 properties in Nearby Cities, and similar 99 Off-Market properties to explore as potential leads

    Opportunities in Nearby Cities

    Here are 4 Similar properties we found in Nearby Locations for your consideration.

    Updated Restaurant in Greenport Village
    $2,850,000
    0.12 Acres

    Updated Restaurant in Greenport Village

    Two-story restaurant with prime commercial location and high visibility.

    48 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944
    View details
    Undeveloped Land in Paradise Point
    $1,499,000
    5.25 Acres

    Undeveloped Land in Paradise Point

    5.25 acres of wooded land in Southold, New York.

    11200 N Bayview Road, Southold, NY 11971
    View details
    Greenport Village Mixed-Use Investment
    Contact for pricing
    4,048 SF

    Greenport Village Mixed-Use Investment

    Mixed-use property in Greenport Village with restaurant, bar, apartments.

    30 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944
    View details
    North Fork Retail Opportunity
    $899,000
    2,606 SF

    North Fork Retail Opportunity

    Retail property in Hamlet Business District with ample parking.

    57190 Route 25, Southold, NY
    View details

    Off-Market Properties in Shelter Island, NY

    Consider similar Off-Market properties in Shelter Island, NY. You may contact the owners directly to inquire about their potential intentions to sell. To help you make a strong first impression, we can assist by reaching out to these owners with compelling proposals created using our AI tool.

    144 Midway Rd

    144 Midway Rd

    OFFICE BUILDING • 1,174 SF
    Value Estimation
    $855,000
    144 Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    27 Fry Rd

    27 Fry Rd

    RESTAURANT • 2,180 SF
    Value Estimation by Request
    27 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    5 Grand Ave

    5 Grand Ave

    VACANT COMMERCIAL LAND • 0.22 Acres
    Value Estimation by Request
    5 Grand Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    6 Fry Rd

    6 Fry Rd

    OFFICE/RESIDENTIAL (MIXED USE) • 1,848 SF
    Value Estimation by Request
    6 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    14th N Cartwright Rd

    14th N Cartwright Rd

    VACANT COMMERCIAL LAND • 1.70 Acres
    Value Estimation by Request
    14th N Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    38 Fry Rd

    38 Fry Rd

    OFFICE BUILDING • 3,979 SF
    Value Estimation
    $2,640,000
    38 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    87 Fry Rd

    87 Fry Rd

    SHOW ROOM, WAREHOUSE • 1,984 SF
    Value Estimation
    $2,070,000
    87 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    25 Fry Rd

    25 Fry Rd

    STORE/OFFICE (MIXED USE) • 1,262 SF
    Value Estimation by Request
    25 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    19 Grand Ave

    19 Grand Ave

    OFFICE/RESIDENTIAL (MIXED USE) • 4,500 SF
    Value Estimation
    $1,455,000
    19 Grand Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    75 Menantic Rd

    75 Menantic Rd

    SHOW ROOM, WAREHOUSE • 3,140 SF
    Value Estimation
    $630,000
    75 Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    188 Fry Rd

    188 Fry Rd

    SHOW ROOM, WAREHOUSE • 2,073 SF
    Value Estimation
    $3,210,000
    188 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    29 Nck Rd

    29 Nck Rd

    RESTAURANT • 3,868 SF
    Value Estimation
    $1,005,000
    29 Nck Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    59 Fry Rd

    59 Fry Rd

    PROFESSIONAL BUILDING • 1,016 SF
    Value Estimation
    $770,000
    59 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    71 Fry Rd

    71 Fry Rd

    SHOW ROOM, WAREHOUSE • 1,756 SF
    Value Estimation by Request
    71 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964-2422
    View details
    74 Fry Rd

    74 Fry Rd

    RETAIL STORES (PERSONAL SERVICES) • 2,163 SF
    Value Estimation
    $620,000
    74 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    26 Fry Rd

    26 Fry Rd

    VACANT COMMERCIAL LAND • 2.60 Acres
    Value Estimation by Request
    26 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    52nd N Fry Rd

    52nd N Fry Rd

    SHOW ROOM, WAREHOUSE • 2,782 SF
    Value Estimation by Request
    52nd N Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964-2414
    View details
    41 Fry Rd

    41 Fry Rd

    OFFICE/RESIDENTIAL (MIXED USE) • 1,846 SF
    Value Estimation by Request
    41 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    36 Fry Rd

    36 Fry Rd

    OFFICE/RESIDENTIAL (MIXED USE) • 2,588 SF
    Value Estimation by Request
    36 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    40 Fry Rd

    40 Fry Rd

    OFFICE/RESIDENTIAL (MIXED USE) • 2,135 SF
    Value Estimation by Request
    40 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964-2414
    View details
    21 Fry Rd

    21 Fry Rd

    SHOPPING CENTER, STRIP CENTER • 3,454 SF
    Value Estimation by Request
    21 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    53 Fry Rd

    53 Fry Rd

    STORE/OFFICE (MIXED USE) • 2,490 SF
    Value Estimation by Request
    53 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details
    85 Fry Rd

    85 Fry Rd

    RESTAURANT • 1,782 SF
    Value Estimation by Request
    85 Fry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    View details

    Shelter Island, NY Commercial Real Estate Investment Opportunities Market Analysis

    Explore 100 commercial real estate for sale in Shelter Island, NY on our real estate platform. These investment opportunities span a total of 3,832 square feet of properties for sale, with an estimated market value of $5,650,000.

    Sale prices for business properties in Shelter Island, NY start at $2,500,000, averaging $2,825,000, and reaching up to $3,150,000 — offering options for a variety of budgets and business needs. Daily updated analytics ensure you stay ahead with the latest data and market trends.

    List
    Map

    Demographics Overview

    Population 2,858
    Median Household Income $129,826
    College Educated 80.7%

    High-Yield Neighborhoods for Strategic Investment

    Identify Shelter Island submarkets with the highest inventory density on the market and evaluate the median listing prices of real estate assets

    Neighborhood Average Price
    11964 $3.2M

    Need Help?

    Reach out if you need assistance with Realmo tools or have questions about your listings

    Browse Commercial real estate for Sale Near Shelter Island, NY

    Popular Searches in Shelter Island, NY

    Most Searched ZIP Codes in Shelter Island, NY

    • 11964

    Select Neighborhood

    Google sign-in failed. Please try again or use another login method.
    Sign Up Successful!
    You now have access to more from Realmo!