Storefront

Sag Harbor, NY Storefront Properties for Lease

Notify Me
List
Map
Watermill, NY Bridgehampton, NY Southampton, NY East Hampton, NY Sagaponack, NY Wainscott, NY Southold, NY Greenport, NY
Three-Road Frontage Retail Space
Updated: Apr 27
Three-Road Frontage Retail Space

2 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$9,890/Mo
744 sqft 0.27 AC lot
744 SF retail space with 620 SF main floor and 124 SF second‑floor storage or office area
Frontage on three separate roads with two customer entrances
Three large southern windows provide natural light to the main floor
Two half baths and rear‑loading double doors
Private employee parking included
View details
End-Cap Retail Storefront
Updated: Nov 21, 2025
End-Cap Retail Storefront

117 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$8,000/Mo
400 sqft 0.03 AC lot
Approximately 400 SF retail space at 117 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
End‑cap position on the south side of a landmark Main Street building
Stone patio with large French doors, display windows, and signage placement
Interior includes a retail floor, changing room, dedicated storage, and Bathroom 1
Jack’s Coffee occupies the north side of the building
View details
Corner Storefront with Walk-Out Basement
Corner Storefront with Walk-Out Basement

138 Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$101 SF/Yr
2,420 sqft  Endcap
Corner location

The first-floor suite has three entry points, including a private Main Street entrance and a rear exit.

Triple-entry access  Private entrance on Main Street  Shared hallway  Private rear exit
View details
3 active listings match your search: Storefront for lease in Sag Harbor, NY. Based on your search, we've also compiled 5 Potential Opportunities for your consideration: 4 spaces in nearby cities and 1 property for sale.

Storefront properties for Lease in Nearby Cities

Here are 4 Similar Spaces we found in Nearby Locations for your consideration.

Flexible-Term Retail Space
Flexible-Term Retail Space

110 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944

$30 SF/Yr
Multi-tenant  1,400–3,500 sqft

Five distinct spaces are offered for pop-up or month-to-month occupancy.

View details
Retail Suite with Dual Exposure
Retail Suite with Dual Exposure

32 Park Place, East Hampton, NY 11937

$10,000/Mo
1,585 sqft

Renovated seasonal space with two bathrooms beside a public parking area and pedestrian route.

View details
Ground-Floor Storefront Retail Space
Ground-Floor Storefront Retail Space

38-44 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944

$25 SF/Yr
Multi-tenant  2,912 sqft  Ground

Adaptable retail space in an established mixed-use building along Front Street near ferry and rail connections.

View details
Renovated Retail Space with Roll Doors
Renovated Retail Space with Roll Doors

9 Railroad Ave, East Hampton, NY 11937

$18,750/Mo
3,000 sqft

Renovated interiors, flexible three-part layout, and visitor parking support retail, gallery, or office use.

High ceilings  Large windows  Garage roll doors  Flexible indoor/outdoor feel
View details

Similar Spaces for Sale in Sag Harbor, NY

Consider Similar Space for Sale. We found 1 Spaces matching your search parameters.

Sag Harbor Mixed-Use Buildings Assemblage
Sag Harbor Mixed-Use Buildings Assemblage

3 Madison Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Contact for pricing
9,032 sqft

Two mixed-use buildings with retail and residential units in Sag Harbor.

View details

Sag Harbor, NY Storefront properties Lease Rates & Market Statistics

Browse 3 Storefront properties for lease in Sag Harbor, NY on Realmo, a commercial real estate marketplace serving the Sag Harbor area. The current inventory totals 1,144 square feet of properties.

Asking lease rates for Storefront properties in Sag Harbor start at $101 SF/Yr, average $166.84 SF/Yr, and reach $240 SF/Yr at the top of the market. Pricing across the market is relatively uniform, which simplifies like-for-like comparison between listings. At $166.84 SF/Yr, the local average runs 403% above New York's state average of $33.17 SF/Yr.

Sag Harbor accounts for 3% of the 94 storefront properties currently available across Suffolk County, where nearby markets include Southampton and Amityville. Storefront properties are one of the more limited space types in Sag Harbor, with just 3 listings currently available — a scarcity worth factoring into lease negotiations.

List
Map
Why this one?