Search
Corner Mixed-Use Building

538 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY 10304

For Sale
Contact for pricing

Four apartments, two retail spaces and a drive-in garage shape the building’s existing configuration.

Property Size7,267 SF
Price / SF$240.81
Days on Market35

Property Features for 538 Bay Street

General Information

Standard status Active
Size 7,267 SF
Property subtype Retail
Zoning C4-2

Property Condition

Severity Major Repairs Needed
Evidence gutted

Site & Location

Corner Location Yes
Public Transit Yes
Mixed-Use Components retail, residential

Units

Unit Mix 4 x 2BR
Multifamily Units 4

Building Details

Buildings 1
Stories 3
Tenancy Multi
Listing Agency: PreReal Prendamano Real Estate
Listed By: Robert Nixon · License NY #10401253010
Source: Crexi
Added: Oct 16 Changed: Nov 14 Last Checked: Nov 18 at 5:55AM

Displayed information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All listing content including descriptions, pricing, images are the copyrighted material of PreReal Prendamano Real Estate

Rey
Ask AI about this property
Review the available facts, identify missing information and prepare questions for the agent.

Investment Insights

Based on property information with market context.

This three-story, 7,267-square-foot corner property is fully vacant and offered in as-is condition. Its layout includes four gutted two-bedroom apartments requiring renovation, two storefronts, and a rear garage with a drive-in door. The corner retail space has more than 40 feet of frontage. The property is zoned C4-2, described as equivalent to R6.

The building is near Urby, the waterfront, the Staten Island Railway and the St. George Ferry, within Staten Island’s North Shore. The existing mix of residential, retail and garage space defines the property’s current physical configuration.

Key Highlights

  • 7,267‑square‑foot, three‑story corner mixed‑use building
  • Four gutted two‑bedroom apartments ready for renovation
  • Two storefronts, including a corner retail space with 40+ feet of frontage

Financial Insights

Estimated NOI and Cap Rate

NOI / Yr
$147,157
Cap Rate
8.41%
Suggested Prices Based on Cap Rates
Cap Rate 5%
$2,943,140 $2.9M
Cap Rate 7%
$2,102,243 $2.1M
Cap Rate 9%
$1,635,078 $1.6M
NOI Build-Up for 7,267 SF
Gross rent
$261.6K
($36.00/SF)
Vacancy
−$26.2K
(−$3.60/SF)
EGI
$235.5K
($32.40/SF)
OpEx
−$88.3K
(−$12.15/SF)
NOI
$147.2K
($20.25/SF)
Market Conditions
Area
ZIP 10304
Vacancy
10.00%
Lease Rate
$36.00 /SF/Yr
Expense Ratio
37.50%
Simulate Cap Rate and NOI
Suggested Prices Based on Cap Rates
Cap Rate 5%
$2,943,140
Cap Rate 7%
$2,102,243
Cap Rate 9%
$1,635,078

Alternative Uses

Best Use
Apartment 5plus
$2.35M
$2.06M – $2.74M (±1% cap)
NOI $164,570 @ 7.0% cap · market cap 9.40%
Second Best
Mixed Use
$2.10M
$1.84M – $2.45M (±1% cap)
NOI $147,157 @ 7.0% cap · market cap 8.41%
Theoretical Best
Office A
$3.47M
$3.03M – $4.05M (±1% cap)
NOI $242,719 @ 7.0% cap · market cap 13.87%
Zoning and permitted uses should be independently verified with authorities. How Realmo checks its estimates

Property Analytics

Current Use

Storefront properties

Suggested Use

Top Pick Real Estate Agency Building Supply Dental Office Big Box & Wholesale Store Auto Parts Store Auto Repair Shop

Score = modeled unmet demand for each use within ~1 mi (higher = bigger opportunity). Zoning and permitted uses should be independently verified with local authorities.

Lease Details

4
Residential units
Multi-tenant
Tenancy

Location Intelligence

Trade Area within ½ mile

1,405
Businesses Nearby

Demographics for 10304, NY

46,944
Population
17,524
Households
2.7
Avg Household Size
38
Median Age
31%
College-Educated
84%
High-School Grad
3.5 sq mi
ZIP Area
13,413
Density / Sq Mi
$71,506
Median Household Income
$41,752
Median Earnings
$1,516
Median Rent
$659,900
Median Home Value

Market

Average Price Trend$/SF for Mixed-use properties in Staten Island, NY

$510 Jul
$457 Aug
$548 Sep
$497 Oct

Properties on Market for Mixed-use properties in Staten Island

Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct

Vacancy Rate% for Multifamily in Northeast region

4% 2022
4.6% 2023
5.3% 2024
5.6% 2025

Frequently Asked Questions

What type of property is this?
Mixed-use property - Four apartments, two retail spaces and a drive-in garage shape the building’s existing configuration.
Where is this mixed-use property located?
The property is located at 538 Bay Street Staten Island, NY.
What is the asking price?
The asking price for this property is $1,750,000.
What are key features of this property?
This property features: 7,267‑square‑foot, three‑story corner mixed‑use building; Four gutted two‑bedroom apartments ready for renovation; Two storefronts, including a corner retail space with 40+ feet of frontage
(718) 816-7799 · Office Call to check price and availability
Research This Page with AI

Rey answers here. ChatGPT, Grok and Claude get the same data packet.

Includes: Price & PSF · Cap rate · Location · Zoning

Ask Rey → ChatGPT Grok Claude
Preferred Make Realmo a preferred source.

Our comps and market reports get this label in your Google results.

Add as a preferred source on Google One click on Google
More about this property
Thanks! Your message was sent.
Error! Your message wasn't sent.
Please enter your name
Please enter email
Please enter the email in the correct format
Please enter phone
Please enter the number in the correct format
Please enter message
Why this one?
Why hide this one?