Chautauqua County, NY Short term rental properties for sale

Updated: Nov 28, 2025

Lakefront Multi-Unit Residential Property

6040 & 6044 Mill Road, Mayville, NY 14757

$490,000

3,176 sqft · 0.43 AC lot

Lake Chautauqua canal access with 105 ft canal frontage and 85 ft with dock
1980‑built 3BR/1BA ranch with single‑level living, central A/C, and enclosed back porch
Updated interior: all areas except the kitchen redone within the last decade (ask for update list)
Duplex includes two 2BR/1BA units, each with separate meters and in‑unit laundry
Accessibility features include an accessible approach with ramp and stairless entry in the lower unit

View details

This listing looks promising.

Here's a quick look at some key insights for

6040 & 6044 Mill Road, Mayville, NY 14757

View Property Analytics

Est. Cap Rate

5.4%
NOI ÷ price
Est. NOI

$26K
Annual
Price @ 7% Cap

$375K
Suggested

View Property Analytics

Updated: Jun 17

Historic Multi-Unit Residential Property

15 Main Street, Bemus Point, NY 14712

$899,000

3,604 sqft · 0.18 AC lot

Historic property built in 1912 with 4 rental units, totaling 6 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms.
About 1 block to Chautauqua Lake and approximately 3 blocks to a public boat launch.
Approximately 2 miles to Long Point State Park sandy beach for swimming and waterfront recreation.
Includes a studio rental with a private porch and a dedicated workspace.
Outdoor features include deck, patio, enclosed porch, balcony, awnings, and a fenced yard.

View details

Sunset Bay Cottages Investment Opportunity

12943 Alleghany Road, Irving, NY 14081

$419,900

735 sqft · 0.27 AC lot

Two updated cottages with vacant lot near Sunset Bay.

View details

Sunset Bay Corner Duplex

954 Charles Street, Irving, NY 14081

$499,900

1,960 sqft · 0.21 AC lot

Rare duplex near marina, beach, and restaurants. Income potential.

View details

Turn Any Listing Into an Investment Snapshot Owner equity, real caprate, demand score for every listing. Go To Analytics Center

Two-Home Rental Duplex

3462 Old Bridge Road, Stow, NY 14785

$219,000

1,698 sqft · 0.12 AC lot

Two rental homes on one property, each with covered outdoor space and recent roof and furnace improvements.

View details

Residential Income Quadplex with Studio Rental

15 Main St, Bemus Point, NY 14712

$899,000

Four rental units plus an on-site studio provide flexible lodging options near Chautauqua Lake attractions.

View details

Two-Home Duplex Rental Property

Stow, NY 14785

$219,000

Two residences on one lot with covered outdoor space and recent roof and heating upgrades for flexible rental use.

View details

Mixed-Use Investment in Downtown Jamestown

24 E 3rd St, Jamestown, NY 14701

$425,000

Mixed-use property with commercial and residential income potential.

View details

Sunset Bay Corner Duplex

Irving, NY 14081

$499,900

Rare bay-corner duplex near marina, restaurants, and beach.

View details

Chautauqua County, NY Short Term Rental Properties Market Trends and Statistics

Explore 9 short term rental properties for sale in Chautauqua County, NY, showcased through 9 active listings on our real estate platform. These investment opportunities span a total of 11,173 square feet of properties for sale, with an estimated market value of $2,527,800.

Sale prices for short term rental properties in Chautauqua County, NY start at $219,000, averaging $505,560, and reaching up to $899,000 — offering options for a variety of budgets and business needs. Daily updated analytics ensure you stay ahead with the latest data and market trends.

Featured Chautauqua County Real Estate Agencies

Realmo connects you with licensed Chautauqua County CRE brokers providing property specifications, local market pricing, and commercial transaction underwriting support.

ERA Team VP Real Estate

Jamestown, NY 14701