Advertise
    Shelter Island, NY
    Multifamily

    Shelter Island, NY Multifamily Properties for Lease

    Notify Me
    List
    Map
    Greenport, NY East Marion, NY Southold, NY Sag Harbor, NY Watermill, NY Bridgehampton, NY East Hampton, NY Wainscott, NY
    Bayfront Cottages: Family Compound Potential
    Updated: Nov 28, 2025
    Bayfront Cottages: Family Compound Potential

    13 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    Contact for pricing
    Bayfront location
    Two renovated cottages, side‑by‑side
    Convertible setup sleeps 4‑8 people
    Can be rented as one unit or individually
    Community tennis, pool, and dock access
    View details
    Turn a Listing Into an Investment Snapshot Cap Rate, Potential NOI, Demand score for every listing. Go To Analytics Center
    Based on your search, we've compiled 5 Potential Opportunities for your consideration. Besides 1 Active listings in Shelter Island, NY, we suggest exploring alternatives. Consider Similar 4 Spaces in Nearby Cities

    Multifamily properties for Lease in Nearby Cities

    Here are 4 Similar Spaces we found in Nearby Locations for your consideration.

    Two-Bedroom Apartment Unit
    Two-Bedroom Apartment Unit

    575 Bank Street Unit 206, New London, CT 06320

    $1,495/Mo
    17,032 sqft

    Unit 206 offers two bedrooms at 575 Bank Street in New London, CT.

    View details
    Renovated Condo with Ocean Views
    Renovated Condo with Ocean Views

    707 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954

    $9,000/Mo
    2.64 AC lot

    One-bedroom condo in Montauk, renovated with ocean views.

    View details
    Montauk Apartment for Rent
    Montauk Apartment for Rent

    16 Navy Rd Unit #111, Montauk, NY 11954

    $8,000/Mo

    Apartment unit available for rent in Montauk, New York.

    View details
    5-Unit Dental-Anchored Mixed-Use Property
    5-Unit Dental-Anchored Mixed-Use Property

    27 Broad St, New London, CT 06320

    Contact for pricing

    Fully leased downtown property combines a dental practice with four upstairs apartments and included heat and hot water.

    View details

    Shelter Island, NY Multifamily properties Lease Rates & Market Statistics

    Explore 1 Multifamily properties listing for lease in Shelter Island, NY on Realmo, a commercial real estate exchange covering the Shelter Island area.

    Shelter Island accounts for 13% of the 8 multifamily properties currently available across Suffolk County, where nearby markets include Montauk and Northport. Multifamily properties are one of the more limited space types in Shelter Island, with just 1 listing currently available — a scarcity worth factoring into lease negotiations.

    List
    Map

    Popular Searches in Shelter Island, NY

    Most Searched ZIP Codes in Shelter Island, NY

    • 11964
    Why this one?
    Saved
    Reason not saved — we won't ask again

    Select Neighborhood

    Google sign-in failed. Please try again or use another login method.
    Sign Up Successful!
    You now have access to more from Realmo!