5880-6020 Mahoning Ave Youngstown, OH 44515

Listing agency Marcus & Millichap - Columbus s***@ipausa.com Show Phone

Listed by Craig Fuller · License #OH 2008001551

Source Crexi

Added: Jul 21 Updated: Jul 22 at 10:38AM Checked: Jul 22 at 10:38AM

Report an Issue

Displayed information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All listing content including descriptions, pricing, images are the copyrighted material of Marcus & Millichap - Columbus

---

Investment Insights

Based on property information with market context.

Austintown Plaza is a 413,836-square-foot shopping center totaling over 38.6 acres and anchored by JCPenney, Pat Catan’s, Planet Fitness and Regal Cinemas. The center is currently 84% occupied and features a mix of national and regional tenants, including Party On, Harbor Freight, Biotest Pharmaceuticals, Brown Aveda Institute, Goodwill, and Mahoning County Board of Commissioners. A majority of existing tenants reimburse for triple net expenses through a combination of pro-rata and fixed NNN lease structures, and several leases extend into the next several years, including Planet Fitness (into 2026), Pat Catan’s (into 2025), Biotest Pharmaceuticals (into 2025), and Harbor Freight (into 2024).

The property is located in a dense retail corridor along Mahoning Avenue, supported by reported traffic of 29,163 vehicles per day. The immediate vicinity includes retailers such as Home Depot, Walmart, Tractor Supply, Dollar Tree, Aldi, Citizens Bank, and Huntington Bank.

Recent capital work includes new roofs installed on approximately 280,000 square feet (67.7% of GLA) since 2010.

Key Highlights

• 413,836 SF shopping center on 38.6+ acres in Austintown, OH, currently 84% occupied
• Anchored by JCPenney (52,305 SF), Pat Catan’s (49,005 SF), Regal Cinemas (29,900 SF) and Planet Fitness (22,024 SF)
• Other major tenants include Harbor Freight, Party On, Biotest Pharmaceuticals, Goodwill, and Mahoning County Board of Commissioners; anchored tenants total 37% of GLA

Property Analytics

Location Intelligence

Similar For Sale Nearby

• 

  $1,000,000

  5,300 SF

  Historic Italian Marketplace For Sale

  Turnkey Italian marketplace established in 1907, a century-old legacy.

  7438 Southern Blvd, Youngstown, OH 44512

  View Details
• 

  $549,500

  11,700 SF

  Connected Downtown Restaurant and Tavern Building

  Two connected brick buildings offer space for restaurant, tavern, retail, and include a 30-car parking lot and available 7-day liquor license.

  200-208 W Front Street, Youngstown, OH, OH 44503

  View Details
• 

  $150,000

  3,000 SF

  Youngstown Commercial Property with Parking

  3000 sqft commercial building with ample parking in Youngstown, OH.

  1535 Logan Avenue, Youngstown, OH 44505

  View Details
• 

  $2,600,000

  14,656 SF

  Riverfront Event Center and Pub

  Recently renovated event center with an adjacent pub and outdoor patio, positioned along the river with downtown views.

  534 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown, OH 44502

  View Details
• 

  $1,100,000

  12,000 SF

  Divisible Clear-Span Flex Building

  New construction flex/industrial building offers clear-span space divisible into four suites with practical expansion options.

  420 Mcclurg Rd, Youngstown, OH

  View Details
• 

  $329,900

  3,011 SF

  Fully Renovated Triplex Investment

  Renovated triplex with three updated units, including a lower-level unit with newly added egress window.

  7217 Pennsylvania Avenue, Youngstown, OH 44514

  View Details
• 

  $749,900

  17,604 SF

  Industrial Flex Facility with Office

  Two-building industrial site includes finished office space, 18-foot ceilings, and overhead doors for flexible manufacturing and storage.

  1104 Andrews Ave, Youngstown, OH

  View Details
• 

  $425,000

  1,909 SF

  Retail Building on Meridian Road

  Retail building for sale with B-2 zoning.

  3516 South Meridian Road, Youngstown, OH, 44511

  View Details
• 

  $127,000

  1,631 SF

  Duplex Home with Detached Garage

  Cape Cod duplex with two full baths, fenced yard, and separate second-floor layout for flexible rental or living arrangements.

  26 N Glenellen Avenue, Youngstown, OH 44509

  View Details
• 

  $139,900

  1,788 SF

  Three-Unit Residential Income Property

  Three-unit income property with separate utilities and major 2024-to-recent updates including new furnaces, water line, and electrical system.

  145 S Lakeview Avenue, Youngstown, OH 44509

  View Details
• 

  $124,900

  936 SF

  Remodeled Mixed-Use Property

  Remodeled mixed-use property featuring modern updates and commercial zoning.

  4258 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown, OH

  View Details
• 

  $105,000

  1,974 SF

  Updated Multi-Family Income Duplex

  Main floor is completed with appliances included, with an unfinished upper level and recent mechanical updates.

  399 W Warren Avenue, Youngstown, OH 44511

  View Details

Similar Off Market Nearby

• Century Square — 5472 Mahoning Ave, Austintown, OH 44515
• Austintown Plaza — 6000 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown, OH 44515
• Quick-Tag — Walmart, 6001 Mahoning Ave, Austintown, OH 44515

FAQs

What type of property is this?

Shopping center - 84% occupied shopping center anchored by JCPenney, Pat Catan’s, Planet Fitness and Regal Cinemas.

Where is this shopping center located?

The property is located at 5880-6020 Mahoning Ave Youngstown, OH.

What are key features of this property?

This property features: 413,836 SF shopping center on 38.6+ acres in Austintown, OH, currently 84% occupied; Anchored by JCPenney (52,305 SF), Pat Catan’s (49,005 SF), Regal Cinemas (29,900 SF) and Planet Fitness (22,024 SF); Other major tenants include Harbor Freight, Party On, Biotest Pharmaceuticals, Goodwill, and Mahoning County Board of Commissioners; anchored tenants total 37% of GLA