Advertise
    New York
    Residential Income

    Sullivan County, NY Residential Income Properties for Sale

    Notify Me
    List
    Map
    Brooklyn, NY New York, NY Bronx, NY Staten Island, NY Queens, NY Buffalo, NY Rochester, NY Albany, NY
    94 properties
    Sort:
    Automotive Garage with Live-Work Space
    Updated: Sep 20, 2025
    Automotive Garage with Live-Work Space

    36 Cold Spring Rd, Monticello, NY 12701

    $974,900
    5,500 sqft
    HC2 zoned property with two buildings and flexible live/work and extended business use.
    Main garage is just under 3,500 SF with five overhead doors of various heights, office, and restroom; currently set up for automotive business.
    Second building is approx. 2,000 SF; formerly a duplex and still has two electric meters, rented by a single tenant (convert back if desired).
    Over 700 ft of road frontage on Cold Spring Road / County Road 102 for vehicle, delivery, and truck access.
    Serviced by municipal sewer and a drilled well; municipal water is approx. 500 ft away.
    View details

    This listing looks promising.

    Here's a quick look at some key insights for

    36 Cold Spring Rd, Monticello, NY

    View Property Analytics

    • Est. Cap Rate

      6.8%
      Above avg (5.9%)

    • Est. NOI

      $66K
      Annual

    • Price @ 7% Cap

      $948K
      Suggested
    View Property Analytics
    Turnkey 5-Unit Townhouse Property
    Updated: Jul 7
    Turnkey 5-Unit Townhouse Property

    100 1/2 Kingston Avenue, Port Jervis, NY 12771

    $1,300,000
    0.52 AC lot
    Built in 1990 and currently 100% occupied with five townhouse‑style apartments
    Approximately 6,706 SF: four 3‑bedroom, 2‑bath units plus one accessible 2‑bedroom, 1.5‑bath single‑level unit
    Recent exterior improvements: new roof, siding, and gutters completed within the past two years
    Over half an acre with each unit featuring a covered front porch, private fenced patio, and dedicated parking space off the driveway
    Tenants are on month‑to‑month leases and pay their own gas, electric, and heat
    View details
    Village-Center Multifamily Building
    Village-Center Multifamily Building

    109 Main Street, Bloomingburg, NY 12721

    $699,900
    0.66 AC lot

    Multi-unit income property on Main Street with off-street parking in Bloomingburg, New York.

    View details
    Multifamily Building with Elevator Access
    Multifamily Building with Elevator Access

    457 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

    $2,999,950
    0.24 AC lot

    Reconstructed and recently renovated multifamily building with elevator access and largely fully occupied units.

    View details
    Turn Any Listing Into an Investment Snapshot Owner equity, real caprate, demand score for every listing. Go To Analytics Center
    Turnkey Five-Unit Townhouse Apartment Building
    Turnkey Five-Unit Townhouse Apartment Building

    100 1/2 Kingston Ave, Port Jervis, NY 12771

    $1,300,000
    6,706 sqft

    Built in 1990, this 5-unit townhouse-style apartment building is turnkey and currently fully occupied.

    View details
    Multi-Building Apartment Campus Fronting Route 209
    Multi-Building Apartment Campus Fronting Route 209

    182 Route 209, Port Jervis, NY 12771

    $1,700,000
    13.60 AC lot

    Six deeded parcels with multiple residences and extensive Route 209 frontage, supported by private wells and septic systems.

    View details
    Brick Mixed-Use Three-Unit Property
    Brick Mixed-Use Three-Unit Property

    6 Short Road, Wurtsboro, NY 12790

    $525,000
    2.50 AC lot

    Three-unit brick property with a 4-bedroom apartment and two office suites, each with separate electric and hot-water heat zoning.

    View details
    Monticello Two-Unit Queen Anne
    Monticello Two-Unit Queen Anne

    97 Liberty Street, Monticello, NY 12701

    $599,900
    0.34 AC lot

    Two-unit Queen Anne with income potential in Monticello, NY.

    View details
    Turnkey Five-Unit Multifamily with Dock
    Turnkey Five-Unit Multifamily with Dock

    48-50 Horseshoe Lake Road, Kauneonga Lake, NY 12749

    $650,000
    3,400 sqft

    Five residential rental units across four buildings, plus a 15-foot-wide lakefront parcel with private dock space.

    View details
    Vacant Lakefront Multifamily Compound
    Vacant Lakefront Multifamily Compound

    238 Lakeview Drive Road, Highland Lake, NY 12743

    $1,189,000
    1.60 AC lot

    Vacant multifamily property with eight independent units across three buildings, each with a kitchen and direct lake frontage.

    View details
    Ranch-Style Duplex with Lake Views
    Ranch-Style Duplex with Lake Views

    1199 State route 52, Loch Sheldrake, NY 12759

    $295,000
    0.25 AC lot

    Ranch-style duplex with two 2-bedroom, 1-bath units, parking for four, and propane heat.

    View details
    Brick Mixed-Use Investment Building
    Brick Mixed-Use Investment Building

    25 Prospect Street, Port Jervis, NY 12771

    $629,000
    11,838 sqft

    Brick mixed-use building with 7 rental units, including residential apartments and business or commercial rentals.

    View details
    Lakefront Laundromat and Apartments
    Lakefront Laundromat and Apartments

    6696 State Route 52, Cochecton, NY 12752

    $550,000
    0.68 AC lot

    For sale mixed-use property with a laundromat and four fully rented apartments on the shoreline of Lake Huntington.

    View details
    Multi-Unit Residential Income Property
    Multi-Unit Residential Income Property

    5039 Main Street, South Fallsburg, NY 12779

    $850,000
    0.70 AC lot

    Triplex-style residential income property with recent renovations and a newly installed septic system.

    View details
    Hurleyville Multifamily Building with Storefront
    Hurleyville Multifamily Building with Storefront

    9 Mongaup Rd, Hurleyville, NY 12747

    $595,000
    4,800 sqft 0.19 AC lot

    Multi-family building with storefront in Hurleyville, NY for sale.

    View details
    Residential Income Property with Multiple Lots
    Residential Income Property with Multiple Lots

    40 Barton Road, Liberty, NY 12754

    $369,000
    5.83 AC lot

    Four separate lots include a year-round 2-bedroom home, two bungalows for rehab, and a vacant buildable parcel.

    View details
    Multifamily Lodge with Lake Ownership
    Multifamily Lodge with Lake Ownership

    40 Sparten Hill Road, Livingston Manor, NY 12758

    $5,400,000
    104.87 AC lot

    Five-building multifamily property with 10 units, set up as a seasonal hunting club and summer retreat.

    View details
    Renovated Two-Family Residence
    Renovated Two-Family Residence

    31 Lumber Street, Port Jervis, NY 12771

    $269,900
    2,552 sqft

    Renovated two-family property with the option to live in one unit and rent the other.

    View details
    Duplex on Acreage with Pond
    Duplex on Acreage with Pond

    118 Old Roosa Gap Road, Bloomingburg, NY 12721

    $579,000
    7.20 AC lot

    Two-unit duplex on 7+ acres with a spring-fed pond, sold as-is and ready for renovation or rental use.

    View details
    Historic Mixed-Use Building with Parking
    Historic Mixed-Use Building with Parking

    9 Thompson Street, Port Jervis, NY 12771

    $499,000
    3,920 sqft

    3,820 sq ft former school structure with ample off-street parking and Delaware River views.

    View details
    Five-Unit Apartment Building
    Five-Unit Apartment Building

    38 Edgar Street, Liberty, NY 12754

    $499,000
    0.29 AC lot

    Well-maintained five-family property offered for sale in Liberty, NY.

    View details
    Resort Lodge and Rental Cabins
    Resort Lodge and Rental Cabins

    374 Neer Road, Long Eddy, NY 12760

    $2,999,000
    6,200 sqft

    Includes five two-bedroom rental cabins, a nearly 5,000 sq. ft. main lodge, and an attached caretaker apartment.

    View details
    Zoned Rural Development Land
    Zoned Rural Development Land

    Hilltop Road, Monticello, NY 12701

    $3,950,000
    413.36 AC lot

    413+ acre parcel with 17 contiguous lots, an access road, and 12 build-ready lots zoned RR-2.

    View details
    Renovated Two-Family Home with Lake View
    Renovated Two-Family Home with Lake View

    1209 State Route 52, Loch Sheldrake, NY 12759

    $329,888
    0.28 AC lot

    Turnkey, renovated 5-bedroom home with rental income potential.

    View details

    Sullivan County, NY Residential Income Properties Market Trends and Statistics

    Explore 94 residential income properties for sale in Sullivan County, NY, showcased through 94 active listings on our real estate platform. These investment opportunities span a total of 83,844 square feet of properties for sale, with an estimated market value of $23,568,700.

    Sale prices for residential income properties in Sullivan County, NY start at $234,000, averaging $1,683,478, and reaching up to $6,999,900 — offering options for a variety of budgets and business needs. Daily updated analytics ensure you stay ahead with the latest data and market trends.

    List
    Map

    Popular Categories

    Featured Sullivan County Real Estate Agencies

    Realmo connects you with licensed Sullivan County CRE brokers providing property specifications, local market pricing, and commercial transaction underwriting support.

    EAGLE VALLEY REALTY
    6569 STATE RT 97 Narrowsburg, NY
    Phone: 18452523085
    Eagle Valley Realty
    6569 State Route 97 Narrowsburg, NY 12764
    Phone: 18452523085
    www.eaglevalleyrealty.com
    Malek Properties
    PO Box 567, 10 Waldheim Road White Lake, NY 12786
    Phone: 18455836333
    www.malekproperties.com

    Select Neighborhood

    Google sign-in failed. Please try again or use another login method.
    Sign Up Successful!
    You now have access to more from Realmo!