Herkimer County, NY Residential income properties for sale

$169,900

2,966 SF

Historic Two-Family Income Property

610-612 E Monroe Street, Little Falls, NY 13365

Spacious 2-unit residence with separate kitchens and full baths, offering flexibility for rentals or owner occupancy.

Built in 1875, this two‑family home offers nearly 3,000 sq ft of living space across two expansive floors.
6 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms total, with each unit featuring its own kitchen and a full bathroom.
Hardwood floors and original woodwork throughout, along with large sun‑filled windows and spacious rooms.
Full basement provides additional storage and utility space.
Detached garage plus on‑street parking, with a paved parking area and a generously sized yard.

Updated: Jun 2

View details

$799,000

3,238 SF

Three Homes and Barn

2704 State Route 28, Thendara, NY 13472

Three homes and a barn on a corner lot.

Three homes and a barn on a .94‑acre corner lot.
Prime location in Old Forge Hamlet.
Potential for Bed and Breakfast or income rentals.
Opportunity for new business development.
Includes natural woodwork and a fireplace.

Updated: May 11

View details

$379,900

1,967 SF

Farm/Estate with Income Potential

10-acre property with barndominium and farmhouse near Hinckley Reservoir.

2192 State Route 8, Cold Brook, NY 13324

View details

$189,900

2,944 SF

Herkimer Duplex: Investment Opportunity

Spacious duplex in Herkimer with separate utilities and income potential.

214-216 N Bellinger Street, Herkimer, NY 13350

View details

$124,900

1,526 SF

Two-Unit Property in Little Falls

Two-unit property with income potential in a prime location.

82 W Monroe Street, Little Falls, NY 13365

View details

$449,000

5,008 SF

Herkimer Five-Unit Investment Property

Renovated, fully occupied investment property with immediate income potential.

516 Steuben rd, Herkimer, NY 13350

View details

$229,000

3,717 SF

Fully Occupied 6-Unit Building

Well-maintained 6-unit apartment building with steady rental income.

18 N Main St, Newport, NY 13406

View details

Fourth Lake Multi-Family Cottage Retreat

$2,500,000

4,426 SF

Fourth Lake Multi-Family Cottage Retreat

Rare 2.4-acre lakefront property with four cottages and rental potential.

150 Kenmore Road, Old Forge, NY 13420

View details

$139,500

2,167 SF

Two-Family Home with Garage

Two-family home featuring updates, yard, and a three-stall garage.

50 Hancock Street, Little Falls, NY 13365

View details

$724,000

3,854 SF

Multi-Unit Retreat Near Adirondacks

Luxury multi-unit property with energy efficiency near Adirondacks.

3595 Military Road, Newport, NY 13416

View details

Herkimer Two-Unit Investment Opportunity

$149,900

1,944 SF

Herkimer Two-Unit Investment Opportunity

Two-unit property in Herkimer, NY with rental potential.

318 S Main Street, Herkimer, NY 13350

View details

$109,900

1,320 SF

Income-Producing Multi-Family Property

Well-maintained multi-family property in Ilion, NY with immediate rental income.

266 Second St, Ilion, NY 13357

View details

Little Falls Multifamily Investment Opportunity

$125,000

3,916 SF

Little Falls Multifamily Investment Opportunity

Three-unit multifamily property in Little Falls with strong rental potential.

32-34 Flint Avenue, Little Falls, NY 13365

View details

$218,500

5,844 SF

Mixed-Use Property in Herkimer, NY

Mixed-use property with retail space and residential units for sale.

246 N Main st, Herkimer, NY 13350

View details

$218,500

5,844 SF

Mixed-Use Investment in Herkimer, NY

Mixed-use property with retail space and residential units.

246 N Main St, Herkimer, NY 13350

View details

Adirondack Park 10-Acre Barndominium Farmhouse

$379,900

10.00 Acres

Adirondack Park 10-Acre Barndominium Farmhouse

10 acres with barndominium and farmhouse in Adirondack Park.

2192 State Route 8, Ohio, NY 13324

View details

$79,900

1,809 SF

Herkimer Two-Unit Investment Opportunity

Two-unit property in Herkimer with rental income potential.

336 N Prospect Street, Herkimer, NY 13350

View details

Versatile Two-Family Residence in Little Falls

$95,000

2,024 SF

Versatile Two-Family Residence in Little Falls

Convertible two-family home near downtown Little Falls.

59 Church Street, Little Falls, NY 13365

View details

$425,000

1,856 SF

Old Forge Multi-Unit Residence

Two-unit property in Old Forge near amenities and attractions.

211 CrosbyBlvd, Old Forge, NY 13420

View details

$109,900

2,168 SF

Updated Duplex in Mohawk Valley

Two-unit property with updated systems in a convenient location.

56 Grove st, Ilion, NY 13357

View details

Turnkey Restaurant and Business Opportunity

$319,000

4,968 SF

Turnkey Restaurant and Business Opportunity

Established restaurant with apartment and parking in Ilion, NY.

154 E Main St, Ilion, NY 13357

View details

$79,900

Dolgeville Two-Unit Investment Property

Charming two-unit property with income potential in a convenient location.

43 W State St, Manheim, NY 13329

View details

$169,900

3,000 SF

Historic Two-Family Duplex Opportunity

A character-rich two-family home with separate kitchens, full baths, and generous interiors for flexible living or rental use.

610-612 E Monroe St, Little Falls, NY 13365

View details

$349,900

4.00 Acres

Turnkey Adirondack Bar and Restaurant

Established bar/restaurant with income potential near snowmobile trails.

3655 State Route 8, Ohio, NY 13324

View details

Herkimer County, NY Residential Income Properties Investment Opportunities Market Analysis

Explore 72 residential income properties for sale in Herkimer County, NY, showcased through 40 active listings on our real estate platform. These investment opportunities span a total of 134,943 square feet of properties for sale, with an estimated market value of $9,426,900.

Sale prices for residential income properties in Herkimer County, NY start at $49,500, averaging $314,230, and reaching up to $2,500,000 — offering options for a variety of budgets and business needs. Daily updated analytics ensure you stay ahead with the latest data and market trends.

Register to start using Rey