Sag Harbor, NY Residential income properties for Rent & Lease

Updated: Dec 19, 2025

Three-Bedroom Income Property

3 Madison Street, Unit 2, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$6,000/Mo

1,342 sqft 0.18 AC lot

1,342‑square‑foot apartment with three bedrooms and one full bath plus a half bath
Flexible arrangement supports three bedrooms or two bedrooms with an office or den
Oversized rear deck provides dedicated outdoor space
Hardwood flooring and steam heat
Constructed in 1989 at 3 Madison Street, Unit 2

View details

Turn a Listing Into an Investment Snapshot Cap Rate, Potential NOI, Demand score for every listing. Go To Analytics Center

Based on your search, we've compiled 9 Potential Opportunities for your consideration. Besides 1 Active listings in Sag Harbor, NY, we suggest exploring alternatives. Consider Similar 4 Spaces in Nearby Cities, and Similar 4 Properties for Sales.

Residential income properties for Lease in Nearby Cities

Here are 4 Similar Spaces we found in Nearby Locations for your consideration.

Renovated 2-Bed Apartment Unit

198 Montauk Avenue Unit 2, New London, CT 06320

$1,950/Mo

725 sqft

Move-in ready 2-bedroom unit with modern finishes, stainless steel appliances, hardwood floors, and off-street parking.

View details

Three-Floor Income Home Rental

47 Perry Street Unit 2, New London, CT 06320

$2,750/Mo

1,920 sqft

Bright 4-bedroom, 2-bath unit with hardwood floors, updated kitchen, and in-unit laundry available immediately.

View details

Renovated Condo with Ocean Views

707 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954

$9,000/Mo

2.64 AC lot

One-bedroom condo in Montauk, renovated with ocean views.

View details

Montauk Apartment for Rent

16 Navy Rd Unit #111, Montauk, NY 11954

$10,000/Mo

Apartment unit available for rent in Montauk, New York.

View details

Similar Spaces for Sale in Sag Harbor, NY

Consider Similar Space for Sale. We found 4 Spaces matching your search parameters.

Two-Family Duplex with Parking

57 JERMAIN AVE, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$1,949,000

1,577 sqft 0.21 AC lot

Historic-district residence with separate living areas, multiple baths, and two kitchens for flexible occupancy.

View details

Live-Work Cottage with Private Patios

12 Rose Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$1,775,000

1,755 sqft 0.11 AC lot

Newly renovated cottage in Sag Harbor Village with fenced patios and off-street parking for up to four cars.

View details

Waterfront Development Land with Home

46 Robertson Drive, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$3,795,000

1.90 AC lot

1.92-acre Sag Harbor-area waterfront parcel with an existing fully livable residence and conceptual plan for additional structures.

View details

Residential Development Parcel with House

37 N View Dr, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

$1,795,000

1.47 AC lot

Estate-sized 1.47-acre parcel with a dated 4BR farmhouse for rebuild or renovation on a quiet residential street.

View details

Sag Harbor, NY Residential income properties Lease Rates & Market Statistics

Browse 1 Residential income properties listing for lease in Sag Harbor, NY on Realmo, a commercial real estate marketplace serving the Sag Harbor area. The current inventory totals 1,342 square feet of properties.

Asking lease rates for Residential income properties in Sag Harbor start at $6,000/Mo, average $6,000/Mo, and reach $6,000/Mo at the top of the market. Pricing across the market is relatively uniform, which simplifies like-for-like comparison between listings.

Sag Harbor, NY Residential Income Properties for Lease

3 Madison Street, Unit 2, Sag Harbor, NY 11963