Financial
Distress signals
Property profile

586 Bay St Staten Island, NY 10304

OFF-MARKET
Investment properties
Property ID
US63-2469634
6,690 SF 0.1 ac lot Built 2002
Last sale Feb 2026 · $1,200,000
Entity Owned Owner of record is a legal entity (LLC / corporation). ~ Est. High Equity Modeled equity is high. Estimate, not a fact.
Saved · see the list in your Dashboard
Market Trends Soon

Property summary

AI-generated overview

This exceptional mixed-use property, located at 586 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10304, presents a lucrative investment opportunity. The building, constructed in 2002, boasts a 4,349 sq ft lot and a substantial 6,690 sq ft of climate-controlled space. The first floor houses a thriving commercial space currently leased as a gym, generating a monthly income of $4,600 with built-in rent increases. The second floor features two completely renovated, two-bedroom, two-bathroom apartments, each

Ownership intelligence

Who controls the opportunity?

Resolved identity, portfolio, hold profile and investor signals. Included in the full report.

Owner contacts

Can we reach the decision maker?

Skip-traced phones and e-mails of the owner. Included with the full report.

Mortgages

What is owed, to whom, and when it comes due

Recorded lenders, amounts and estimated maturities of the owner's loan book — in the full report.

Property tax · 2024

What does the county charge?
$13k
Tax billed · 2024
Assessed value$64k
Assessed land$15k
Assessed improvement$49k
Effective rate20.08%

Value estimate

· Sep 2026
$1.05M
$945k – $1.16M
Sales comparison$1.03M

Realmo valuation models over county records and 43 qualifying comparable sales.

Recently sold

What actually traded nearby?
$238/SF
ZIP average, outlier-cleaned · 52 recorded sales of this use type
Observed band · Q1–Q3$155 – $302
Qualifying comparables43

Cap rate analysis

How does the asset earn?

No income signal is modeled for this parcel yet — the Cap Rates tab runs the workflow.

Zoning insight

What can be built here?
C4-2
This district comprise the City major and secondary shopping and business centers, which provide for shopping needs and services over a w...
General categoryCOMMERCIAL
JurisdictionRICHMOND

Location intelligence

Which uses thrive at this corner?
Best fit: Tailor Shop
Demand index
Tailor Shop11.1
Realty agency11.0
Computer & Electronic Repair10.7

Location

586 Bay St Staten Island, NY 10304-3847
County assessor Recorded deeds · 3 transfers 43 qualifying comp sales Zoning catalog

Every figure names its source: public record, benchmark, or modeled. Coverage varies by property — thin data is stated as missing, never invented.

Comparables

6 recorded sales · 12 properties nearby
Recent sales nearby
6 recorded sales in this ZIP, last 8 years
Address Sale price Sold Size
171 Broad, Staten Island, NY 10304-2057 $950,000 Feb 2026 6,400 SF
663 Bay, Staten Island, NY 10304-3828 $999,999 Jul 2024 7,650 SF
190 Cebra, Staten Island, NY 10304-2243 $690,010 Oct 2023 9,675 SF
49 Norwood, Staten Island, NY 10304-3710 $365,000 Sep 2023 4,146 SF
442 Bay, Staten Island, NY 10304-3818 $1,380,000 Sep 2023 5,244 SF
896 Targee, Staten Island, NY 10304-4517 $980,000 Jul 2023 4,789 SF
Sale prices and dates as our records hold them, one row per building. A deed can cover more of a building than the size shown, so read the price against the size rather than dividing one by the other.
Comparable nearby
6 properties of the same type nearby
Try Rey
Ask anything about this address in plain English.
“Is 15.6% cap rate sustainable?” · “Best tenant mix for BU1?” · “What’s the redev upside?”
You own 586 Bay St?
List it free. Reach 20,000 daily buyers.
We’ve already pulled the facts. Confirm photos + price and you’re live in 2 minutes.
More about this property
Thanks! Your message was sent.
Error! Your message wasn't sent.
Please enter your name
Please enter email
Please enter the email in the correct format
Please enter phone
Please enter the number in the correct format
Please enter message