Property summary
This iconic Windham, NY, mixed-use property, located at 5344 NY-23, presents a unique investment opportunity. The 7,635 square foot building sits on a 0.2-acre lot in the heart of Windham's bustling Main Street, offering exceptional visibility and foot traffic. Currently 100% occupied, the property generates substantial income from a ground-floor retail space (formerly Todaro's, now The Main Street Market) and three upstairs one-bedroom, one-bathroom apartments. This established business and… residential combination provides a dual income stream, ensuring a steady cash flow. The retail space is ideal for a variety of businesses, catering to both locals and the town's significant tourist population. The apartments have a history of long-term tenants. Seller financing is available. An additional, separately deeded, buildable lot is available for purchase, offering potential for expansion or development of additional retail or residential space. Municipal water and sewer services are available. This property offers flexibility for owner-operators or investors seeking strong rental income in a desirable location. The building's prime location and established reputation make it a valuable asset in a growing community. This is more than just a building
Ownership intelligence
Resolved identity, portfolio, hold profile and investor signals. Included in the full report.
Owner contacts
Skip-traced phones and e-mails of the owner. Included with the full report.
Mortgages
Recorded lenders, amounts and estimated maturities of the owner's loan book — in the full report.
Property tax
No data for this sectionNo tax or assessment record is on file for this parcel in the county feed.
Value estimate
· Sep 2026No data for this sectionNo value estimate could be modeled: the record carries too little market input for this parcel.
Recently sold
No data for this sectionNo cleaned sale $/SF benchmark exists for this use type in this ZIP, submarket or county yet.
Cap rate analysis
No income signal is modeled for this parcel yet — the Cap Rates tab runs the workflow.
Zoning insight
No data for this sectionNo zoning code is on file for this parcel. Coverage grows with every catalog release.
Location intelligence
Demand index: how under-served this business type is around this point — modeled from the LocInt grid (area demand vs. what already operates, adjusted by real visit traffic). Higher means stronger unmet demand.
Location
Every figure names its source: public record, benchmark, or modeled. Coverage varies by property — thin data is stated as missing, never invented.
Comparables
6 recorded sales · 10 properties nearbyComparable nearby
Similar Nearby for Sale
Instant AI valuation built from comps, income signals, and proprietary benchmarks.A defensible range, not a single guess.
from $99/month
- GBA
- 7,635 SF
- Lot area
- 0.2 ac
Cap rate calculated from real income and expense signals, benchmarked against sales of similar assets nearby.
from $99/month
The recorded zoning designation, what the district officially allows, and the municipal source it comes from.
No zoning code is on file for this parcel. Zoning coverage grows with every catalog release — check back, or open Location Intelligence for use analysis of this corner.
Phones and e-mails of the people behind this property's owner, traced from licensed contact data.
Owner phones and e-mails come with the full report for this property - traced from licensed contact data, with verification and Do-Not-Call flags on every number.
Unlock the evidence behind ownership: portfolio, transactions, debt and signals that help you decide who to contact next.
Registration is required before any owner information is shown.
The mortgage data is behind the paid report: recorded loans of the owner - lender, amount, rate and the estimated maturity - as part of the Ownership Intelligence workspace.
Registration is required before any owner information is shown.
- Ownership
- Owner Contacts
- Full Property Data
- Historical Records
- Value Estimation
- NOI Potential
- Cap Rate Calculation
- Location Insight
- Alternative use
- Local Zoning Insight
Cancel anytime.
- 30 reports a month
- Ownership
- Owner Contacts
- Location Analytics
- Everything in the Light report
- Full Property Data
- Historical Records
- Value Estimation
- NOI Potential
- Cap Rate Calculation
- Location Insight
- Alternative use
- Local Zoning Insight
Cancel anytime.
- 300 reports a month
- Ownership
- Owner Contacts
- Location Analytics
- Everything in the Light report
- Full Property Data
- Historical Records
- Value Estimation
- NOI Potential
- Cap Rate Calculation
- Location Insight
- Alternative use
- Local Zoning Insight
and get 1 Light Report
- Full Property Data
- Historical Records
- Value Estimation
- NOI Potential
- Cap Rate Calculation
- Location Insight
- Alternative use
- Local Zoning Insight
The PDF can’t be displayed here
Use Download PDF or Open in new tab above to view the sample report.
