Commercial Real Estate Market in Mystic Island, NJ
Updated monthly: sale, lease, property records, location trend, and more… · Last update: September 30
117 active listings and 273 off-market properties in Mystic Island, NJ. Commercial property asks $395/SF to buy and $15.62/SF/Yr to lease.
Market Trends
Figures below refresh monthly; last updated 30 September 2026.
Office
Office space in Mystic Island, NJ asks $320/SF to buy. Vacancy runs 19.9% across the Northeast region in 2025, up from 13.1% in 2019.
Average Sale Price $/SF
Listings
Vacancy Rate % in Northeast region
Retail
Retail space in Mystic Island, NJ asks $406/SF to buy. Vacancy runs 6% across the Northeast region in 2025, little changed from 6% in 2019. Down from a 2020 peak of 7.1%.
Average Sale Price $/SF
Listings
Vacancy Rate % in Northeast region
Industrial
Industrial vacancy in Mystic Island, NJ runs 7.6% across the Northeast region in 2025, up from 5.4% in 2019. Nearly 2.4x the 2021 low of 3.2%.
Vacancy Rate % in Northeast region
Multifamily
Multifamily space in Mystic Island, NJ asks $406/SF to buy. Vacancy runs 5.6% across the Northeast region in 2025, up from 4% in 2022.
Average Sale Price $/SF
Listings
Vacancy Rate % in Northeast region
Market overview
Tools
Nearby Markets
| Market | Average Sale Price, $/SF | Average Lease Price, $/SF/Yr |
|---|---|---|
| Tuckerton | $395 (county avg) | $15.62 |
| Eagleswood Township | $395 (county avg) | — |
Commercial property in Mystic Island, NJ asks $395/SF. The 2 bordering markets run from $395/SF in Tuckerton to $395/SF in Tuckerton, and the city sits in line with their $395/SF median.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the average price per square foot for commercial property in Mystic Island?
Commercial property in Mystic Island, NJ asks an average of $395 per square foot. The 4 most recent recorded sales traded at a median of $748/SF. Multifamily carries the highest asking price at $406/SF.
How much does it cost to lease commercial space in Mystic Island?
Asking lease rates in Mystic Island, NJ average $15.62 per square foot per year.
How does Mystic Island compare to nearby markets on price?
Mystic Island, NJ asks $395/SF against $395/SF in Tuckerton and $395/SF in Eagleswood Township.
Where does Realmo's Mystic Island market data come from?
Realmo compiles Mystic Island, NJ figures from 7 recent recorded sales, 100 active sale listings, 17 active lease listings, 273 tracked off-market properties. Sale and lease figures refresh monthly; vacancy annually. Last updated 30 September 2026.
Methodology & data sources
- Asking prices and averages
- Computed from 100 active for-sale and 17 active for-lease listings in Mystic Island, NJ. These are ASKING figures from live listings, not closed-transaction prices, and a segment carried by a handful of listings reads as indicative rather than an average.
- Price per square foot
- The county-level $/SF blends closed sales aggregated over the trailing months of available data, not a single day's snapshot — it can differ from any one month's own median.
- Vacancy rates
- Published per-sector market series, taken at the metro level where one exists and otherwise at the Census-region level — a chart reading "in <region> region" is a regional number, not this city's.
- Refresh
- The monthly aggregates close at the end of the previous month, so 30 September 2026 — not today — is the honest last update.
- Known limitations
- office vacancy is reported at Northeast region level, retail vacancy is reported at Northeast region level and industrial vacancy is reported at Northeast region level.
- Coverage
- Metrics below the 10-observation threshold fall back one geographic level. The geography used is named on each figure.
Compiled by the Realmo Data team · reviewed 30 September 2026 · report a data issue
