5869 Broadway St, Lancaster, NY 14086

Building Details

Year Built

1896

Listing agent Md Nazmul Hussain Show Phone

Listing office m***@huntrealestate.com Show Phone

Listing date Apr 28, 2026

Source Elliman

Displayed information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

All listing content including descriptions, pricing, images are the copyrighted material of Md Nazmul Hussain

Report an issue

---

Overview

This completely renovated 2-unit multi-family property in Lancaster offers strong income potential and modern upgrades throughout. Each unit features 3 bedrooms, a living room, a formal dining room, a full kitchen, and 1 full bathroom. The lower unit also includes an additional half bathroom. Recent updates include new kitchens, new bathrooms, new flooring throughout, fresh interior paint, updated lighting fixtures, and a new HVAC system. The property is in move-in ready condition with extensive improvements already completed. The spacious layouts in both units make this property ideal for owner-occupants or investors. It is conveniently located near shopping, restaurants, and major roadways. This is a turnkey opportunity in a desirable suburban location. The square footage differs from the tax records; see the floor plan in the attachments.

Suggested Use

Real Estate Agency Law Firm Restaurant Spa & Massage Center Dental Office Hair Salon Nail Salon Building Supply Gym & Fitness Center Daycare Center

Zoning and permitted uses should be independently verified with local authorities.

Location Insight

• Map
• Local Demand

City

Lancaster

County

Erie

State

New York

Longitude

-78.639072

Latitude

42.8951908

Nearby Similar for Sale

• 

  $649,000

  9,856 SF

  Corner Mixed-Use Retail and Apartments

  Two-building corner property with storefront retail space, apartments, and separate utilities with month-to-month tenancy.

  5476 Broadway Street, Lancaster, NY 14086

  View Details
• 

  $289,900

  1,852 SF

  Lancaster Duplex: Turnkey Investment Gem

  Well-maintained Lancaster duplex, ideal for investment or owner-occupancy.

  372 Aurora Street, Lancaster, NY 14086

  View Details
• 

  $329,900

  1,960 SF

  Updated Duplex in Lancaster Village

  Charming, updated 2-unit property in the heart of Lancaster.

  5302 Broadway Street, Lancaster, NY 14086

  View Details
• 

  $224,899

  1,072 SF

  Renovated Two-Unit Building

  Completely renovated two-unit building near West Main Street.

  17 Saint Marys Street, Lancaster, NY 14086

  View Details
• 

  $2,100,000

  31,500 SF

  Flex Space Investment Opportunity

  Flex space investment property with long-term tenants and zero vacancies.

  491 Erie St, Lancaster, NY 14086

  View Details
• 

  $460,000

  6,103 SF

  Versatile Lancaster Commercial Building

  6,103 sq ft building with showroom, office, and basement.

  3568 Walden Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086

  View Details
• 

  $669,000

  1,000 SF

  Mixed-Use Investment Opportunity in Lancaster

  Mixed-use property with retail and residential units in Lancaster Village.

  5476 Broadway St, Lancaster, NY 14086

  View Details
• 

  $500,000

  12,188 SF

  Renovated Office Building in Lancaster

  Extensively renovated office building with parking in historic village downtown.

  5400 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086

  View Details
• 

  $439,900

  Mixed-Use Property in High-Traffic Area

  Mixed-use property with commercial space and residential apartments for sale.

  3284 Walden Ave, Lancaster, NY 14043

  View Details
• 

  $500,000

  2,994 SF

  Retail Property in Lancaster, NY

  Retail property available for sale in Lancaster, New York.

  5383 Broadway, Lancaster, NY

  View Details
• 

  $3,500,000

  32,500 SF

  Newer Industrial/Commercial Building For Sale

  32,500 SF industrial/commercial building with office space in Lancaster, NY.

  18 Lancaster Pkwy, Lancaster, NY, 14086-9713

  View Details
• 

  $275,000

  2,337 SF

  Broadway Street Auto Shop Opportunity

  Auto shop with detached home and high-visibility frontage.

  6526 Broadway St, Lancaster, NY

  View Details

FAQs

What type of property is this?

Duplex - Completely renovated 2-unit property with strong income potential.

Where is this duplex located?

The property is located at 5869 Broadway St Lancaster, NY.

What is the asking price?

The asking price for this property is $359,900.

What are key features of this property?

This property features: Completely renovated 2‑unit multi‑family property with strong income potential.; Each unit features 3 bedrooms, living room, formal dining room, full kitchen, and full bathroom.; Recent updates include new kitchens, new bathrooms, new flooring, fresh paint, updated lighting, and new HVAC.