Allegany County, NY Specialty properties for sale

Versatile Commercial Building in Angelica, NY

$349,900

40,716 SF

Versatile Commercial Building in Angelica, NY

21 E Main St, Angelica, NY 14709

4.8-acre commercial building in historic Angelica, NY, with redevelopment potential.

40,000+ sq ft commercial building on 4.8 acres in the Village of Angelica, NY.
Ideal for redevelopment: mixed‑use, office complex, senior living, community center, etc.
Features a large gymnasium with auditorium and a commercial‑grade kitchen.
Walking distance to Main Street, Park Circle, post office, and library.
Minutes from Interstate I‑86, providing regional connectivity.

Updated: Aug 15, 2025

View details

Commercial Investment Opportunity in Black Creek

$89,900

1,200 SF

Commercial Investment Opportunity in Black Creek

6391 Ny-305, Black Creek, NY 14714

Well-maintained commercial property with long-term rentals and income.

Leased to the United States Post Office, providing stable, long‑term income.
Additional income from a one‑bedroom apartment rental.
Low‑maintenance block exterior and recently installed metal roof.
Well‑maintained property.
Convenient location near Cuba, Cuba Lake, and Seneca Oil Spring Casino.

Updated: Dec 29, 2025

View details

$64,900

Scio Church Building with Redevelopment Potential

Church property in Scio, NY, with redevelopment opportunities.

3915 Cottage Bridge Rd, Scio, NY 14880

View details

$215,000

Village Church with Additional Building

Two-parcel property with church and multi-use building in Almond.

7371 South Main St, Almond, NY 14804

View details

$175,000

Former Church with Redevelopment Potential

Well-maintained church on 0.66 acres in Andover, NY.

24 Elm St, Andover, NY 14806

View details

$244,900

Belmont NY Commercial Building

90,000 sq ft building on 3.9 acres in Belmont.

34 South St, Belmont, NY 14813

View details

$59,999

Former School Building on 4.55 Acres

47,991 SF former school in Rushford, NY, on 4.55 acres.

9114 Hardys Corners Rd, Cuba, NY 14727

View details

$225,000

Bolivar Church and Parish Hall

Redevelopment opportunity in the heart of Bolivar, New York.

111 Wellsville St, Bolivar, NY 14715

View details

Explore Off-Market Properties in Allegany County, NY

Consider similar Off-Market properties in Allegany County, NY. You may contact the owners directly to inquire about their potential intentions to sell. To help you make a strong first impression, we can assist by reaching out to these owners with compelling proposals created using our AI tool.

9099 Hardys Cor Rd

Churches & religious facilities • 2,562 SF

Value Estimation by Request

9099 Hardys Cor Rd, Rushford, NY 14777

View details

6383 Peacock Hl Rd

PROFESSIONAL CLUBS/ASSOCIATIONS • 2,028 SF

Value Estimation

$245,000

6383 Peacock Hl Rd, Angelica, NY 14709

View details

Main St

VETERINARY, ANIMAL HOSPITAL • 912 SF

Value Estimation

$240,000

Main St, Scio, NY 14880

View details

9041 County Rd 16

CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION • 2,218 SF

Value Estimation

$250,000

9041 County Rd 16, Canaseraga, NY 14822

View details

County Rd 18

PROFESSIONAL CLUBS/ASSOCIATIONS • 1,692 SF

Value Estimation

$280,000

County Rd 18, Wellsville, NY 14895

View details

Andover, NY 14806

SBE - SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS

Value Estimation by Request

Andover, NY 14806

View details

2350 State Rte 275

CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION • 1,664 SF

Value Estimation

$235,000

2350 State Rte 275, Bolivar, NY 14715

View details

101 Ww Ave

FUNERAL HOME • 3,032 SF

Value Estimation

$255,000

101 Ww Ave, Angelica, NY 14709

View details

5425 Rte 305

CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION • 6,132 SF

Value Estimation

$245,000

5425 Rte 305, Cuba, NY 14727

View details

137 Brooklyn St

PROFESSIONAL CLUBS/ASSOCIATIONS • 2,220 SF

Value Estimation

$215,000

137 Brooklyn St, Angelica, NY 14709

View details

3978 County Rd 10

PROFESSIONAL CLUBS/ASSOCIATIONS • 2,640 SF

Value Estimation by Request

3978 County Rd 10, Scio, NY 14880

View details

2784 County Rd 2a

CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION • 1,600 SF

Value Estimation

$255,000

2784 County Rd 2a, Almond, NY 14804

View details

Special Fran

SBE - SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS

Value Estimation by Request

Special Fran, Belmont, NY 14813

View details

5425 Rte 305

CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION • 3,250 SF

Value Estimation

$260,000

5425 Rte 305, Cuba, NY 14727

View details

Bolivar, NY 14715

SBE - SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS

Value Estimation by Request

Bolivar, NY 14715

View details

Bolivar, NY 14715

SBE - SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS

Value Estimation by Request

Bolivar, NY 14715

View details

Allegany County, NY Specialty Properties Investment Opportunities Market Analysis

Explore 248 specialty properties for sale in Allegany County, NY, showcased through 8 active listings on our real estate platform. These investment opportunities span a total of 15,452,282 square feet of properties for sale, with an estimated market value of $5,719,800.

Prices for properties in Allegany County, NY start at $89,900, averaging $248,686, and reaching up to $349,900 — offering options for a variety of budgets and business needs. Daily updated analytics ensure you have the most current data.

Allegany County, NY Specialty Properties for Sale

Versatile Commercial Building in Angelica, NY

4.8-acre commercial building in historic Angelica, NY, with redevelopment potential.

Commercial Investment Opportunity in Black Creek

Well-maintained commercial property with long-term rentals and income.