Property Lookup
Property Lookup
  • For Sale
  • For Lease
  • Recently Sold
  • Property Lookup
  • Brokers
Property profile & analytics

3872 Erie St Willoughby, OH 44094

  • Commercial real estate
  • 1.53 lot acres
OFF-MARKET
Value Estimation
Location Intelligence

Current Use by Public Records

  • Norfolk Southern / Railroad Company
  • Willoughby Ghost Walk / Tour Agency
  • Spirits in WIlloughby / Bar & Grill
  • WILLOUGHBY COAL / Building Materials Supplier / Hardware Store

Property Details for 3872 Erie St

Year built
1888
Lot size
1.53 lot acres
Property type
Commercial real estate

Description

This exceptional offering presents a rare chance to acquire two adjacent properties in Willoughby, Ohio's vibrant entertainment district. The package includes Spirits in Willoughby, a 4,800 square foot contemporary entertainment venue, and the historic Willoughby Coal Supply building, a 7,500 square foot landmark dating back to 1888. Spirits in Willoughby boasts a fully equipped commercial kitchen, a horseshoe bar, Ohio Lottery Keno, and the area's largest patio, perfect for hosting large-scale events, live music, and seasonal dining. Unique outdoor amenities include a gazebo, fire pit, and bocce ball courts, along with a repurposed train car adding to its distinctive character. The adjacent Willoughby Coal Supply building, a significant piece of local history, features original wood floors and offers ample space for events, tours, or adaptive reuse. Its fenced outdoor area and ample parking provide additional versatility. Both properties benefit from a prime location within the Entertainment District, surrounded by thriving developments, and offer significant potential for a variety of uses, including boutique hotels, craft beverage establishments, or expanded event venues. The combined 1.53-acre lot provides ample space for future development and expansion. This unique pairing presents a transformative opportunity to redefine hospitality and entertainment in Downtown Willoughby. The properties are offered at $2,400,000.

Value Estimation

Powered by Realmo proprietary methodology Last update: July 3, 2025
  • CAP approach

  • Comparable approach

  • Alternative Use

Location Insight

  • Map
  • Local Demand
City
Willoughby
County
Lake
State
Ohio
Longitude
-81.4074
Latitude
41.6447
More about this property
Thanks! Your message was sent.
Error! Your message wasn't sent.
Please enter your name
Please enter email
Please enter the email in the correct format
Please enter phone
Please enter the number in the correct format
Please enter message