5818 E New York Street, Indianapolis, IN 46219

Building Details

Year built

1914

Floors in Building

2

Number of units

2

Building materials

Aluminum Siding

Architectural style

Other

Listing agent Amber Russell License #RB14047686 Show Phone

Listing office Keller Williams Indy Metro NE k***@kw.com River Rd Ste 200 8555, Indianapolis, IN Show Phone

Listing date May 29, 2026

Report an issue

MLS# 22104506 Listing URL

Copyright © 2026 MIBOR Service Corporation. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

---

Overview

This historic residential property features spacious living areas with original character, including hardwood floors and abundant natural light. The layout is designed to support both everyday living and entertaining, with room to spread out rather than a purely compartmental plan. Outdoors, the home includes a detached garage and a large backyard, offering practical added convenience and private space.

Set on a tree-lined street in Irvington, the property benefits from a neighborhood feel while still being close to daily amenities. The surrounding area includes local shops and restaurants, as well as nearby parks and access to downtown Indianapolis, described as just minutes away.

For an owner-occupant, the combination of classic interior details and outdoor space can support comfortable long-term living. For investors or operators, the residence’s flexible interior layout and detached garage make it a straightforward option to consider within a residential income strategy, subject to confirming specific rentability and lease terms. Prospective buyers should review the home’s condition and suitability for their intended use, with particular attention to the layout and how the outdoor space and detached garage fit their needs.

Suggested Use

Law Firm Skin Care Clinic HVAC Service Electrical Service Gym & Fitness Center Parking Lot & Garage (Bike/Boat/Book/etc) Store (Bike/Boat/Book/etc) Store Storage Facility Daycare Center

Zoning and permitted uses should be independently verified with local authorities.

Location Insight

• Map
• Local Demand

City

Indianapolis

County

Hamilton

State

Indiana

Longitude

-86.067597

Latitude

39.772217

Nearby Similar for Sale

• 

  $685,000

  Restaurant/QSR With Drive-Thru Potential

  Restaurant-ready space with recent upgrades, signalized access, and prominent visibility along a major northside retail corridor.

  5527 N Keystone Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

  View Details
• 

  $550,000

  Hard-Corner Retail/Office Building

  C-3 zoned building on a hard corner with strong traffic exposure, onsite parking, and flexible retail or office use.

  5243 Rockville Road, Indianapolis, IN 46224

  View Details
• 

  $3,900,000

  Elevator-Served Mixed-Use Building

  Well-maintained mixed-use building in CBD-2 with elevator service, dry sprinkler system, and on-site parking for tenants and visitors.

  536 E Market Street, Indianapolis, IN 46204

  View Details
• 

  $560,000

  Flexible Office Building with Detached Garage

  C-1 zoned building with a fenced outdoor area and detached garage, suited for office or education-oriented uses.

  2131 E 54th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

  View Details
• 

  $3,800,000

  Industrial Flex with Multiple Overhead Doors

  Industrial flex building on I-3 zoned land with office space and two 14-ft overhead doors for vehicle-ready operations.

  1000 S Arlington Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46203

  View Details
• 

  $2,475,000

  Renovated Office Flex Complex

  Multi-tenant office and flex space with common parking and five leasable suites offering flexible occupancy options.

  9130 Otis Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46216

  View Details
• 

  $4,350,000

  Heavy Industrial Dock-High Warehouse

  49,000 SF heavy industrial facility with multiple dock-high doors, office buildout, and 16'4" clear height.

  2334 Production Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46241

  View Details
• 

  $1,000,000

  Corner Two-Tenant Retail and Auto Site

  Remodeled two-tenant corner property in C-5 zoning, positioned for retail and auto-related business uses near major corridors.

  1121 E Troy Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46203

  View Details
• 

  $700,000

  Multi-Office Building with Private Parking

  Commercial-office building with 16 offices, large windows, and a private parking lot near major thoroughfares.

  1300 N Pennsylvania Street, Indianapolis, IN 46202

  View Details
• 

  $524,900

  Two-Level Office Building with Conference Rooms

  Two-level office building with conference rooms, kitchenette, multiple offices, and restrooms, plus a finished lower level.

  2226 W Michigan Street, Indianapolis, IN 46222

  View Details
• 

  $1,200,000

  Auto Shop with Paint Booth

  Automotive repair facility with a custom paint booth, office, and multiple work bays supported by front and rear vehicle access.

  7086 Southeastern Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46239

  View Details
• 

  $149,000

  Four-Unit Retail Value-Add Property

  Four-unit retail asset on two parcels along a heavily traveled corridor, offered as-is and requiring significant improvements.

  3427 W Michigan Street, Indianapolis, IN 46222

  View Details

FAQs

What type of property is this?

Single family property - Hardwood floors, spacious interiors, and a large backyard with detached garage add flexibility for owner or renter.

Where is this single family property located?

The property is located at 5818 E New York Street Indianapolis, IN.

What is the asking price?

The asking price for this property is $185,000.

What are key features of this property?

This property features: Historic home built in 1914 with aluminum siding; Basement included; Detached garage