Back to Search

Historic Church with Versatile Space

24 Pine Street, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View on Map

For Sale

$295,000

Three-story church with over 7,500 SF of versatile space.

Type:Commercial

Property size:

7,700 SF

Lot size:

0.83 Acres

Price / SF:

$38/SF

HighLights

Expansive 7,500+ sq ft three‑story building with versatile space.
Prime downtown location with excellent visibility and historic landmark status.
Grand sanctuary featuring a beautiful altar, elegant pendant lighting, and striking stained‑glass windows.
Fully equipped kitchen and spacious banquet hall ideal for events and gatherings.
Multiple offices, meeting rooms, and gathering spaces offering flexible layouts.
All‑brick construction with timeless architectural charm and green space.

We can help!

Listing Contact

CHAD J MAJEWSKI

For Sale

$295,000

Three-story church with over 7,500 SF of versatile space.

Type:Commercial

Property size:

7,700 SF

Lot size:

0.83 Acres

Price / SF:

$38/SF

Added:: Oct 10, 2025
Days on Market:: 244
Last Refresh:: Apr 5 at 9:20 pm

Property Features for 24 Pine Street

General Information

Standard status: Active
Size: 7,700 SF
Lot size: 0.83 Acres
Property subtype: Commercial

We can help!

Listing Contact

CHAD J MAJEWSKI

Listing agent CHAD J MAJEWSKI License #10371201846

Listing office CHAD MAJEWSKI REAL ESTATE

Listing date Oct 10, 2025

Source Corcoran

Displayed information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

All listing content including descriptions, pricing, images are the copyrighted material of CHAD MAJEWSKI REAL ESTATE

HighLights

Expansive 7,500+ sq ft three‑story building with versatile space.
Prime downtown location with excellent visibility and historic landmark status.
Grand sanctuary featuring a beautiful altar, elegant pendant lighting, and striking stained‑glass windows.
Fully equipped kitchen and spacious banquet hall ideal for events and gatherings.
Multiple offices, meeting rooms, and gathering spaces offering flexible layouts.
All‑brick construction with timeless architectural charm and green space.

Overview

Located in downtown Amsterdam, this all-brick, three-story church offers over 7,500 square feet of space. The main level features a grand sanctuary with an altar, pendant lighting, and stained-glass windows. Additional levels include multiple offices, meeting rooms, and gathering spaces. The lower level includes a fully equipped kitchen and a spacious banquet hall. The property has green space and extends from block to block. It can continue its use as a church or be repurposed for residential, daycare, event, or creative use. The property also has a 4 bed 1.5 bath that can be included, but is currently listed separately.

Property Profile Location Intelligence

Current Use by Public Records

St Luke's Lutheran ... Church Church of God Strong ... Church

Suggested Use

Location Insight

Map
Local Demand

City: Amsterdam
County: Montgomery
State: New York
Longitude: -74.1972
Latitude: 42.9425

Nearby Similar for Sale

$125,000

3,807 SF

Versatile Commercial Space Near Train

3,800+ SF commercial space ideal for manufacturing or storage.

8 Yeoman Street, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View Details
$230,000

3,024 SF

Meticulously Maintained Historic Residence

Cherished historic home with original details and rare double lot.

357 Division Street, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View Details
$180,000

8,760 SF

Spacious Light-Industrial Building on NY-5

8,760 sq ft commercial building with high-traffic visibility.

397 West Main Street, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View Details
$199,900

1,978 SF

Two-Family Residence Investment

Two-family home in Amsterdam, fully occupied on month-to-month terms for investors or owner-occupants.

3 Young Avenue, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View Details
$282,000

2,696 SF

Two-Family Home with Screened Porch

Well-maintained two-family residence with updated bathrooms, newer windows, and outdoor porches for flexible living arrangements.

168-170 Brookside Avenue, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View Details
$265,000

2,294 SF

Charming Two-Family Home

Two-unit home with modern upgrades and desirable amenities.

22-24 Kreisel Terrace, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View Details
$699,900

1,512 SF

Equestrian Training Center Opportunity

Equestrian training center with track, arenas, and boarding facilities.

802 QUEEN ANN ROAD, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View Details
$169,000

2,460 SF

Spacious Two-Family Home For Sale

Two-unit property with flexible living options and income potential.

74 James Street, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View Details
$340,000

10,085 SF

Historic Amsterdam Property for Renovation

Charming property in Amsterdam, NY, offering unique renovation potential.

49 E Main Street, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View Details
$195,000

2,458 SF

Remodeled Two-Family Home, Amsterdam

Recently remodeled two-family home in Amsterdam, great investment opportunity.

225-227 Grand Street, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View Details
$180,000

1,104 SF

Remodeled Two-Unit Amsterdam Property

Fully remodeled, move-in ready two-unit property in Amsterdam, NY.

24 Slater Street, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View Details
$175,000

8,000 SF

Versatile Industrial Building in Amsterdam

8,000 sq ft warehouse and office space for sale.

11 Edward Street, Amsterdam, NY 12010

View Details

What type of property is this?

Church & religious facility - Three-story church with over 7,500 SF of versatile space.

Where is this church & religious facility located?

The property is located at 24 Pine Street Amsterdam, NY.

What is the asking price?

The asking price for this property is $295,000.

What are key features of this property?

This property features: Expansive 7,500+ sq ft three‑story building with versatile space.; Prime downtown location with excellent visibility and historic landmark status.; Grand sanctuary featuring a beautiful altar, elegant pendant lighting, and striking stained‑glass windows.