Historic Church Property with Assembly
New
For Sale
$699,000
1926 and 1928 Route 44/55, Modena, NY 12548
Commercial Sale, Modena, NY
Property Size10,729 SF
Lot Size0.90 Acres
Price / SF$65.15
Days on Market2
Property Features for 1926 and 1928 Route 44/55
General Information
Property type
Commercial Sale
Property subtype
Other
Zoning
BD40
Rooms
Basement
Parking features
Parking Lot, Off Street
Elementary school
Plattekill Elementary School
Middle school
John G Borden Middle School
High school
Wallkill Senior High School
Elementary school district
Wallkill
Middle school district
Wallkill
High school district
Wallkill
Directions
Route 32 to Main Street (Route 44). Located right in the 'heart" of Modena.
Standard status
Active
APN
4200-101.001-0002-003.000-0000
Lot size
0.90 Acres
Taxes and HOA fees
Tax Year
2025
Utilities
Utilities
Cable Available
Sewer type
Septic Tank
Heating system
Hot Water(Heating), Oil, Baseboard
Cooling system
Central Air
Water source
Well
Building Details
Year built
1855
Floors in Building
2
Flooring type
Wood, Combination
Building materials
Frame
Listing Agency:
RE/MAX Town & Country · Redefy
(845) 765-6128
Listed By:
Susan Wynne · License #30WY0742303
(845) 222-0610
Added: Sep 4
Changed: Sep 5
Last Checked: Sep 5 at 5:06AM
MLS# 1046459
Copyright © 2026 OneKey MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
Investment Insights
Based on property information with market context.
This three-building property spans two lots and combines a historic church, a substantial assembly hall, and a three-bedroom parsonage. Built in 1855, the church measures 3,370 square feet and features stained-glass windows, hardwood flooring, open ceilings, a second-floor mezzanine, and detailed trim. The 6,078-square-foot assembly hall includes a gymnasium, stage, kitchen, hall, and meeting rooms. A 1,281-square-foot parsonage adds a front porch, rear deck, and established residential functionality.
The property encompasses 0.90 acres along the Route 44/55 corridor in Modena and is zoned BD40. Its established building footprint is exempt from the standard 300-foot centerline setback. The site includes an off-street parking lot, well water, septic service, central air, and oil-fired hot-water baseboard heat. The church and parsonage received new roofs in 2015.
The property encompasses 0.90 acres along the Route 44/55 corridor in Modena and is zoned BD40. Its established building footprint is exempt from the standard 300-foot centerline setback. The site includes an off-street parking lot, well water, septic service, central air, and oil-fired hot-water baseboard heat. The church and parsonage received new roofs in 2015.
Key Highlights
- 0.90‑acre, three‑building compound across 2 lots
- 3,370‑square‑foot historic church built in 1855
- 6,078‑square‑foot assembly hall with gymnasium, stage, kitchen, hall, and meeting rooms
Property Analytics
Current Use
Lease Details
Yes
Highway access
Yes
Paved road access
Location Intelligence
Trade Area within ½ mile
18
Businesses Nearby
Explore this area
Business Placement
Demographics for 12548, NY
1,334
Population
354
Households
3.8
Avg Household Size
42
Median Age
45%
College-Educated
98%
High-School Grad
3.9 sq mi
ZIP Area
342
Density / Sq Mi
$114,191
Median Household Income
$55,366
Median Earnings
$1,914
Median Rent
$327,800
Median Home Value
Questions? Ask Rey
Realmo’s AI knows this listing — price, zoning, demand, history. Ask anything.
Frequently Asked Questions
What type of property is this?
Church & religious facility - Three-building commercial compound with BD40 zoning, assembly space, a parsonage, parking, and established residential use.
Where is this church & religious facility located?
The property is located at 1926 and 1928 Route 44/55 Modena, NY.
What is the asking price?
The asking price for this property is $699,000.
What are key features of this property?
This property features: 0.90‑acre, three‑building compound across 2 lots; 3,370‑square‑foot historic church built in 1855; 6,078‑square‑foot assembly hall with gymnasium, stage, kitchen, hall, and meeting rooms
