Your AI Navigator in Commercial Real Estate
Sign Up Successful!
You now have access to more from Realmo!
    For Sale
    • For Sale
    • For Lease
    • Recently Sold
    • Property Lookup
    • Brokers
    AI Search
    Back to Search

    52 S Midway Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964

    Sponsored
    For Sale
    $3,750,000

    Farm / Farmhouse, Residential - Shelter Island, NY

    Type:Farm
    Property size:
    2,200 SF
    Lot size:
    0.88 Acres
    Days on Market:
    41
    Last Refresh:
    Jan 5 at 4:06 pm

    Property Features for 52 S Midway Rd

    General Information

    Property type
    Residential
    Property subtype
    Farm
    Standard status
    Active
    Rooms
    Basement, Bathroom 1, Bathroom 2, Bathroom 3, Bedroom 1, Bedroom 2, Bedroom 3, Bedroom 4, Dining Room, Kitchen, Living Room
    Bedrooms
    4
    Bathrooms
    3
    APN
    0700-019.000-0001-018.000
    Parking features
    Garage
    Fireplace
    1
    Basement Y/N
    1
    Appliances
    Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator, Washer
    Size
    2,200 SF
    Lot size
    0.88 Acres

    Utilities

    Heating system
    Fireplace(s), Forced Air, Oil, Wood (Heating), Wood Stove
    Cooling system
    Central Air

    Building Details

    Year built
    1908
    Year renovated
    1908
    Floors in Building
    2
    Flooring type
    Hardwood
    Building materials
    Cedar
    Architectural style
    Other

    The Agency Hamptons

    Listing agent Shane Donahue (631) 899-3224

    Listing date Nov 26, 2025

    MLS# 11541620 Listing URL

    Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

    Overview

    Renovated Waterfront Farmhouse with Dock

    Located near Turkem's Rest and a short distance from Salt and Shipwreck, this renovated farmhouse on Shelter Island offers 4 bedrooms and dates back to approximately 1908. Situated on 0.88 acres, the property overlooks Menantic Creek and includes a substantial dock, providing panoramic water views and southwestern exposure for sunsets. The landscaping, designed by Marders, features mature specimen plantings and outdoor spaces, including a patio, south lawn, and screened porch. The renovated farmhouse, designed by architect Kitty McCoy, features a mud room vestibule. The gourmet kitchen includes a breakfast area and French doors leading to the stone patio. The dining room features restored original trim and a built-in cabinet. The living room has two sitting areas, a fireplace, and a bay window seat, leading to a wraparound screened porch with water views. The interiors, styled by Culpepper Interiors, feature Holly Hunt window and Philip Jeffries wall coverings, complemented by fixtures from Ralph Lauren, RH, and antique sources. A full bath and outdoor shower are located on the main level. Upstairs, four bedrooms and two updated baths feature Waterworks fixtures and water views. The property has 400 feet of frontage. The property offers potential pool locations, including a south-facing waterside pool. The property size is 2200 square feet.
    Property Profile Insight Report Location Intelligence

    Current Use by Public Records

    Single family properties

    Map

    City
    Shelter Island
    County
    Suffolk
    State
    New York
    Longitude
    -72.340534
    Latitude
    41.055922

    Nearby Similar for Sale

    • $2,200,000
      2,640 SF

      Turnkey Restaurant on 1.26 Acres

      East End restaurant and property for sale on 1.26 acres.
      63 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
      View Details
    • $2,500,000
      1,632 SF

      Shelter Island Home For Sale

      Residential property in The Hamptons, Shelter Island, New York.
      25 W Nck Rd, Shelter Island, NY
      View Details

    FAQs

    What type of property is this?
    Farm - Shelter Island farmhouse with water views, dock, and sunset exposure.
    Where is this farm located?
    The property is located at 52 S Midway Rd Shelter Island, NY.
    What is the asking price?
    The asking price for this property is $3,750,000.
    What are key features of this property?
    This property features: - Waterfront property with 400 feet of frontage, a substantial dock, and panoramic southwestern-facing water views for magical sunsets.; - Recently renovated, turnkey 4-bedroom farmhouse, circa 1908, combining original charm with modern updates.; - Professionally landscaped shy acre by Marders with mature specimen plantings, exceptional outdoor spaces including a stone patio, breezy south lawn, and idyllic screened porch.
    (510) 333-3317
    Request Owner's contact information
    52 S Midway Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Message sent successfully
    Error
    If you are the owner or broker of this property and would like to edit or remove this listing please send a message to web site administrator.
    52 S Midway Rd
    Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Message sent successfully
    Error
    Email to Your Friends
    Link copied to clipboard
    Separate multiple addresses with a comma
    Message sent successfully
    Error

    Realmo Value Estimation

    Realmo estimates a property’s market value using a proprietary methodology that incorporates public data and user-submitted information. This cumulative value is generated by integrating a variety of conventional and innovative methods. 

    Disclaimer

    These figures are not official appraisals and should not be used as a substitute for a valuation performed by a licensed appraiser.

    Actual market value may differ due to factors not captured in the data. Estimates are offered for informational purposes only, and users should conduct independent research before making financial or investment decisions.

    By using this feature, you acknowledge that Realmo is not responsible for actions taken based on these estimates.

    AI approach

    Realmo AI Method estimates property value using machine learning models trained on millions of comparable listings, transactions, and market signals. It analyzes property features, location intelligence data, and current market dynamics to predict the most probable market value in real time.

    Cap approach

    Capitalization Method calculates value based on estimated net operating income (NOI) and applying a market-based capitalization rate (cap rate), we estimate what a typical investor might be willing to pay for it.

    Comparable approach

    Comparable estimate is based on recent sales of similar nearby properties, adjusted for factors like size, condition, and location.

    Relative

    Relative property class coefficient uses factors that account for typical price differences between various asset types (e.g., retail vs. industrial) to provide a more accurate market-aligned estimate.

    Geo

    Comparable Sales Method, enhanced by Geo coefficients — location-based adjustment factors that reflect differences in price levels across neighborhoods, cities, or regions ensuring a more accurate, market-sensitive valuation.

    Alternative use

    Estimate considers the property’s potential value if used for a different purpose-based on zoning, demand, and market feasibility.

    More about this property
    52 S Midway Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964
    Thanks! Your message was sent.
    Error! Your message wasn't sent.
    Please enter your name
    Please enter email
    Please enter the email in the correct format
    Please enter phone
    Please enter the number in the correct format
    Please enter message
    Google sign-in failed. Please try again or use another login method.
    Create New Password
    • At least 8 characters
    • Contains both letters and numbers
    • Contains uppercase and lowercase letters
    • At most 32 characters
    • Password required
    • Password reset link has expired. Please request a new one.