Renovated Waterfront Farmhouse with
52 S Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Farm / Farmhouse, Residential - Shelter Island, NY
Type:Farm
Property size:
2,200 SFLot size:
0.88 AcresPrice / SF:
$1,431/SF- Added:
- Jul 11, 2025
- Days on Market:
- 302
- Last Refresh:
- May 8 at 10:06 pm
Property Features for 52 S Midway Rd
General Information
- Property type
- Residential
- Property subtype
- Farm
- Bedrooms
- 4
- Bathrooms
- 3
- Rooms
- Basement, Bathroom 1, Bathroom 2, Bathroom 3, Bedroom 1, Bedroom 2, Bedroom 3, Bedroom 4, Dining Room, Kitchen, Living Room
- Parking features
- Garage
- Fireplace
- 1
- Basement Y/N
- 1
- Appliances
- Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator, Washer
- Standard status
- Active
- APN
- 0700-019.000-0001-018.000
- Size
- 2,200 SF
- Lot size
- 0.88 Acres
Taxes and HOA fees
- Tax Annual Amount
- 11865
Utilities
- Heating system
- Fireplace(s), Forced Air, Oil, Wood (Heating), Wood Stove
- Cooling system
- Central Air
Building Details
- Year built
- 1908
- Year renovated
- 1908
- Floors in Building
- 2
- Flooring type
- Hardwood
- Building materials
- Cedar
- Architectural style
- Other
Listing agent Shane Donahue (510) 333-3317
Listing office The Agency Hamptons 2462 Main Street, #1, Bridgehampton, NY (631) 899-3224
Listing date Jul 11, 2025
MLS# 11541620
Listing URL
Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
HighLights
- Waterfront property with 400 feet of frontage, a substantial dock, and panoramic southwestern‑facing water views for magical sunsets.
- Recently renovated, turnkey 4‑bedroom farmhouse, circa 1908, combining original charm with modern updates.
- Professionally landscaped shy acre by Marders with mature specimen plantings, exceptional outdoor spaces including a stone patio, breezy south lawn, and idyllic screened porch.
- Gourmet kitchen with breakfast area and French doors to the patio, plus a gorgeous dining room with restored original trim and built‑in cabinet.
- Luxuriously updated bathrooms with Waterworks fixtures, complemented by high‑end finishes.
- Potential for a south‑facing waterside pool.
Overview
Located near Turkem's Rest and a short distance from Salt and Shipwreck, this renovated 4-bedroom farmhouse, built around 1908, is situated on approximately 0.88 acres overlooking Menantic Creek. The property includes a substantial dock and offers panoramic water views with southwestern exposure. The landscape, designed by Marders, features mature plantings and outdoor spaces, including a patio, south lawn, and screened porch. The farmhouse, restored and modernized by architect Kitty McCoy, features a gourmet kitchen with a breakfast area and French doors to the stone patio. The dining room includes restored original trim and a built-in cabinet. The living room has two sitting areas, a fireplace, and a bay window. The wraparound screened porch offers water views. The interiors, styled by Culpepper Interiors, feature Holly Hunt window and Philip Jeffries wall coverings, complemented by fixtures from Ralph Lauren and RH. The main level includes a full bath and outdoor shower. Upstairs, there are four bedrooms and two updated baths with Waterworks fixtures. The property has 400 feet of frontage. A site examination suggests two potential pool locations, including a south-facing waterside pool that conforms to zoning setbacks and requires no variance.
Property Profile
Insight Report
Location Intelligence
Current Use by Public Records
Waterfront Land
Map
- City
- Shelter Island
- County
- Suffolk
- State
- New York
- Longitude
- -72.340534
- Latitude
- 41.055922
Nearby Similar for Sale
FAQs
What type of property is this?
Farm - Shelter Island farmhouse with water views, dock, and renovated interiors.
Where is this farm located?
The property is located at 52 S Midway Rd Shelter Island, NY.
What is the asking price?
The asking price for this property is $3,150,000.
What are key features of this property?
This property features: Waterfront property with 400 feet of frontage, a substantial dock, and panoramic southwestern‑facing water views for magical sunsets.; Recently renovated, turnkey 4‑bedroom farmhouse, circa 1908, combining original charm with modern updates.; Professionally landscaped shy acre by Marders with mature specimen plantings, exceptional outdoor spaces including a stone patio, breezy south lawn, and idyllic screened porch.
