Amagansett, NY Conventional restaurants for Rent & Lease

Updated: Mar 25

Restaurant Building with Patio

74A Montauk Highway, Amagansett, NY 11930

$48,611/Mo

2,830 sqft 0.77 AC lot

2830 SF former diner on a 0.77‑acre property
Indoor seating for 100+ guests plus an outdoor patio
Bar, new kitchen equipment, updated mechanicals, and multiple walk‑ins
Full basement with a legal prep area for catering and off‑site production
31 parking spots on site

View details

Updated: Mar 28

Turnkey Restaurant with Open Patio

74 Old Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930

Contact for pricing

2,830 sqft 0.77 AC lot

Fully built‑out South‑of‑the‑Highway restaurant at 74A Montauk Highway in Amagansett
126‑seat layout with interior dining plus an open patio (96 inside / 30 outside; alterable accordingly)
Oversized kitchen with newer professional equipment, multiple walk‑ins, and full finished basement with legal prep area
Renovated in 2020 with ceramic tile flooring, central A/C, and gas service
2,830 SF main level plus finished lower level, with indoor/outdoor flow and office/back‑of‑house areas

View details

Turn a Listing Into an Investment Snapshot Cap Rate, Potential NOI, Demand score for every listing. Go To Analytics Center

Based on your search, we've compiled 6 Potential Opportunities for your consideration. Besides 2 Active listings in Amagansett, NY, we suggest exploring alternatives. Consider Similar 4 Spaces in Nearby Cities

Conventional restaurants for Lease in Nearby Cities

Here are 4 Similar Spaces we found in Nearby Locations for your consideration.

Equipped Restaurant with Large Kitchen

341-345 Bank St, New London, CT 06320

$4,000/Mo

4,330 sqft

Restaurant space with a large, fully equipped kitchen, bar seating for 20, and dining for 180.

View details

Wet-Use Restaurant and Bar Space

87 North Road, Hampton Bays, NY 11946

Contact for pricing

1,700 sqft

Ground-level wet-use commercial space of about 1,700 SF, available for lease in Hampton Bays.

View details

Waterfront Restaurant with Wraparound Deck

363 Beach Road, Hampton Bays, NY 11946

$18,750/Mo

8,160 sqft

Newly renovated oceanfront restaurant with water-view dining areas, multiple bars, and a full-service kitchen.

View details

Conventional Restaurant with Bar

341 Bank St, New London, CT 06320

Contact for pricing

4,330 sqft

Dining space includes seating areas, private-party areas, and a bar-and-grill configuration.

View details

Amagansett, NY Conventional restaurants Lease Rates & Market Statistics

Explore 2 Conventional restaurants for lease in Amagansett, NY on Realmo, a commercial real estate exchange covering the Amagansett area. The current inventory totals 5,660 square feet of properties.

Conventional restaurants lease rates in Amagansett range from $206.12 SF/Yr at the entry level to $206.12 SF/Yr at the top of the market, averaging $206.12 SF/Yr. Pricing across the market is relatively uniform, which simplifies like-for-like comparison between listings. At $206.12 SF/Yr, the local average runs 145% above New York's state average of $84.10 SF/Yr.

Amagansett accounts for 13% of the 16 conventional restaurants currently available across Suffolk County, where nearby markets include Hampton Bays and Riverhead. Conventional restaurants are one of the more limited space types in Amagansett, with just 2 listings currently available — a scarcity worth factoring into lease negotiations.