For sale
Conventional restaurants
IL
Aurora
28-40 West New York St

Aurora Commercial Building For Sale

28-40 West New York St, Aurora, IL

View on Map

For Sale

Contact for pricing

Multi-unit building with restaurant, banquet space, and leased basement.

Type:RETAIL

Property size:

20,460 SF

Lot size:

0.33 Acres

Price / SF:

$124/SF

HighLights

New roof and HVAC units installed in 2024.
Building is currently separated into four units, offering diverse income potential.
Majority of the first floor is owner‑occupied as a restaurant/tavern.
Second floor offers approximately 6,380 +\/- SF, currently utilized as banquet space.
Basement level is leased to a haunted house, providing existing rental income.
500 +\/- SF vacant space on the first floor.

We can help!

Listing Contact

Dan J Dolan

Learn more

For Sale

Contact for pricing

Multi-unit building with restaurant, banquet space, and leased basement.

Type:RETAIL

Property size:

20,460 SF

Lot size:

0.33 Acres

Price / SF:

$124/SF

Added:: May 6, 2025
Days on Market:: 409
Last Refresh:: May 20 at 9:08 pm

Property Features for 28-40 West New York St

General Information

Standard status: Active
Size: 20,460 SF
Lot size: 0.33 Acres
Property subtype: RETAIL

We can help!

Listing Contact

Dan J Dolan

Listing agent Dan J Dolan License #471009420

Listing office Dolan & Murphy Inc

Listing date May 6, 2025

Source Moodyscre

Displayed information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

All listing content including descriptions, pricing, images are the copyrighted material of Dolan & Murphy Inc

HighLights

New roof and HVAC units installed in 2024.
Building is currently separated into four units, offering diverse income potential.
Majority of the first floor is owner‑occupied as a restaurant/tavern.
Second floor offers approximately 6,380 +\/- SF, currently utilized as banquet space.
Basement level is leased to a haunted house, providing existing rental income.
500 +\/- SF vacant space on the first floor.

Overview

The building is currently separated into four units. The majority of the first floor is owner-occupied as a restaurant/tavern, with a 500 square foot vacant space on the far east end of the building. The second floor, approximately 6,380 square feet, is currently owner-occupied and utilized as banquet space in conjunction with the first-floor restaurant and tavern areas. The basement level is leased to a haunted house. New roof and HVAC units were installed in 2024. The property size is 20,460 square feet and is located in Aurora, IL.

Location Intelligence

Current Use by Public Records

Conventional restaurants

Suggested Use

Location Insight

Map
Local Demand

City: Aurora
County: Kane
State: Illinois
Longitude: -88.315
Latitude: 41.7593

Nearby Similar for Sale

$710,000

2,122 SF

Versatile Office Property in Aurora

Office-zoned commercial property with development potential in Aurora's Tanner District.

442 N Lake Street N, Aurora, IL 60506

View Details
$750,000

1,313 SF

Built-Out Single-Story Office Condos

Two fully built-out office condos are available for sale with tenants already in place and abundant parking onsite.

3845 MCCOY Drive, Aurora, IL 60504

View Details
$280,000

3,800 SF

Downtown Aurora Commercial Building For Sale

Highly visible building ideal for retail, office, or restaurant.

209 E Galena Boulevard, Aurora, IL 60505

View Details
$375,000

Renovated Office Condo Suite

Renovated office suite with private offices, conference space, and multiple rooms for professional or medical use.

1256 Waterford Drive, Aurora, IL 60504

View Details
$199,000

Aurora Commercial Building for Sale

Architecturally striking commercial building in Aurora's revitalizing downtown corridor.

220 E Galena Boulevard, Aurora, IL 60505

View Details
$420,000

All-Brick Church on Corner Lot

All-brick church on a corner double lot with flexible interior space and parking for more than 30 vehicles.

15 S East Avenue, Aurora, IL 60505

View Details
$350,000

1,000 SF

Former Union Hall Office Building

Two-story building with meeting hall, suitable for various uses.

412 hankes Avenue, Aurora, IL 60505

View Details
$550,000

6-Unit Apartment Building

Updated 6-unit with a new roof, tenant-paid utilities, and on-site parking for each unit.

168 S Lincoln Avenue, Aurora, IL 60505

View Details
$1,025,000

Six-Unit Multifamily Property with Parking

Solid six-unit property with garage parking and potential rent increases.

1740 Felten Road, Aurora, IL 60505

View Details
$650,000

Profitable Auto Repair Business Included

Thriving auto repair business with real estate in Aurora, IL.

1349 E New York Street, Aurora, IL 60505

View Details
$449,000

2,800 SF

Historic Mixed-Use Building in Aurora

Two-story mixed-use building in Aurora's historic downtown district.

26 E Downer Place, Aurora, IL 60505

View Details
$1,600,000

Turnkey 9-Unit Apartment Building

Well-renovated 9-unit multifamily with split ductless HVAC, coin laundry, and designated parking for each unit.

304 Hankes Avenue, Aurora, IL 60505

View Details

For sale
Conventional restaurants
IL
Aurora
28-40 West New York St

What type of property is this?

Conventional restaurant - Multi-unit building with restaurant, banquet space, and leased basement.

Where is this conventional restaurant located?

The property is located at 28-40 West New York St Aurora, IL.

What is the asking price?

The asking price for this property is $2,550,000.

What are key features of this property?

This property features: New roof and HVAC units installed in 2024.; Building is currently separated into four units, offering diverse income potential.; Majority of the first floor is owner‑occupied as a restaurant/tavern.

28-40 West New York St, Aurora, IL

Multi-unit building with restaurant, banquet space, and leased basement.

Property Features for 28-40 West New York St

General Information

We can help!

HighLights

Overview

Current Use by Public Records

Suggested Use

Location Insight

Nearby Similar for Sale

Versatile Office Property in Aurora

Built-Out Single-Story Office Condos

Downtown Aurora Commercial Building For Sale

Renovated Office Condo Suite

Aurora Commercial Building for Sale

All-Brick Church on Corner Lot

Former Union Hall Office Building

6-Unit Apartment Building

Six-Unit Multifamily Property with Parking

Profitable Auto Repair Business Included

Historic Mixed-Use Building in Aurora

Turnkey 9-Unit Apartment Building

FAQs

Create New Password